The Hong Kong Polytechnic University · FACULTY OF FINANCE

AF5326 Chap.3 CAPM, Cost of Capital and WACC

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 3 of 4 · AF5326

CAPM, Cost of Capital and WACC

Price the risk that remains

Beta measures how much an asset moves with the market, the risk a diversified investor cannot remove. CAPM combines the risk-free rate, market risk premium and beta to obtain the required return on equity.

The same number becomes the firm’s cost of equity and supplies one side of the capital-cost calculation.

Blend current opportunity costs

WACC combines the cost of equity with the current after-tax cost of debt using market-value weights. It is a project hurdle only when operating risk and target financing resemble the firm.

A different business line needs a project-specific rate built from comparable operations rather than the company name or funding source.

Interpret every CAPM input

The risk-free rate compensates for waiting without default risk, the market premium prices one unit of systematic exposure and beta counts the units carried by the asset.

Standard deviation is not inserted because its firm-specific part can be diversified. A beta above one raises the equity return required when the market premium is positive; a beta below one reduces it.

The calculation becomes economically meaningful only after the result is identified as the opportunity cost for shareholders facing comparable market risk.

Use current values on both sides

WACC is forward-looking, so historical coupons and book equity are poor default inputs. The debt cost should reflect current yield to maturity or a current borrowing rate, then be reduced for the interest tax shield.

Equity value comes from the market price of the ownership claim, and debt value should be measured on the same date where possible.

Market weights and current component returns describe what capital providers require now; mixing them with accounting balances from another date creates a precise but incoherent average.

Check the project before accepting the hurdle

A firmwide WACC is suitable only when the project resembles existing operations in business risk and will be financed near the target mix.

A retailer entering data centres should not inherit the retail hurdle merely because the same company signs the cheque. Pure-play comparables can provide operating evidence for a project beta, which is then combined with an appropriate financing assumption.

The funding source does not determine the discount rate: retained earnings have an equity opportunity cost, and cheap debt does not make risky operating cash flows safe.

Audit the final number

The weighted average should normally fall between the cost of equity and the after-tax cost of debt.

Capital weights must sum to one, debt alone receives the tax adjustment and a higher beta should raise equity cost when other market inputs are fixed. These checks reveal unit, weight and tax errors before a project decision is stated.

The closing step is to compare the project return with the hurdle or discount matching operating cash flows; reporting WACC without naming the eligible cash flows leaves the analysis unfinished.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Beta as market co-movement

  • 02

    Drivers of beta

  • 03

    CAPM required return

  • 04

    Security market line

  • 05

    Current cost of debt

  • 06

    Debt tax shield and market weights

  • 07

    Firmwide and project-specific WACC

Worked example · free

Build WACC from current market inputs

Q [10 marks]. This mark allocation divides the solution for practice and is not the University’s official assessment scheme. A firm has HK$5.4 billion equity and HK$3.6 billion debt. Beta is 1.15, the risk-free rate 3%, market premium 6.5%, debt yield 5% and tax 16.5%. Find WACC.
Equity contributes 6.285 points and after-tax debt contributes 1.670 points.Equity contributes 6.285 points and after-tax debt contributes 1.670 points. The bar widths show 60/40 market-value financing and the lower box adds the weighted capital costs to 7.955%.Market-value weights turn required returns into WACCEquity 60%10.475% costDebt 40%4.175% after tax6.285% + 1.670%WACC = 7.955%Bar widths are 60:40; contribution labels equal weight multiplied by cost.
Equity contributes 6.285 points and after-tax debt contributes 1.670 points. The bar widths show 60/40 market-value financing and the lower box adds the weighted capital costs to 7.955%.
  • 4Find market-value weights and cost of equity.
  • 2Find after-tax debt cost.
  • 4Blend and state the comparability condition.
The weights are 60% equity and 40% debt. CAPM gives 10.475% cost of equity and debt costs 4.175% after tax. WACC is 0.60(10.475%) + 0.40(4.175%) = 7.955%, approximately 7.96%. It suits projects with similar risk and financing.
Sia tip — Treat every input as forward-looking. Old coupons and book equity describe history, while WACC prices the capital held now.
Glossary

Key terms

Beta
Systematic risk relative to the market, measured from return co-movement.
Risk-free Rate
The return for deferring consumption without market risk in the model.
Market Risk Premium
The expected market return above the risk-free rate.
Cost Of Equity
The return required by shareholders on the current market value of equity.
After-tax Debt
The current debt cost after recognising the interest tax deduction.
Pure-play Comparable
A listed business used to estimate the risk of a project outside the firm’s usual operations.
FAQ

CAPM, Cost of Capital and WACC FAQ

Why does CAPM use beta instead of standard deviation?

Diversified investors can remove firm-specific volatility without giving up expected return, so the market does not reward that avoidable burden. Beta isolates the portion that co-moves with the market and survives diversification. CAPM prices units of that systematic exposure through the market risk premium.

Why is the bond coupon not the cost of debt?

The coupon was fixed when the bond was issued and is a historical contract. WACC needs the opportunity cost of borrowing now, measured by current yield to maturity or a new borrowing rate. A bond trading below par can have a current debt cost well above its coupon.

When should a firm avoid its own WACC?

Avoid the firmwide rate when the project’s business risk differs materially from existing operations or its target financing differs from the firm’s mix. Use pure-play comparable betas to build a project-specific return. One rate across unrelated divisions accepts too many risky projects and rejects too many safe ones.

Study strategy

Exam move

Create a WACC worksheet with four boxes: market weights, CAPM equity cost, current after-tax debt cost and comparability. Fill each box from a fresh problem before blending. Then draw a security market line and place one underpriced and one overpriced asset relative to the CAPM benchmark. Explain the price movement that would return each to equilibrium without using the words good or bad.

Working through CAPM, Cost of Capital and WACC in AF5326? Sia is AskSia’s AI Finance tutor — ask any AF5326 CAPM, Cost of Capital and WACC question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how AF5326 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 24 of your subjects at The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your AF5326 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works