The Hong Kong Polytechnic University · FACULTY OF ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING

EE535 Chap.10 Risk, Criticality and RCM Decisions

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 10 of 10 · EE535

Risk, Criticality and RCM Decisions

Risk links evidence to a required response

Risk-based asset management focuses attention by considering consequence and occurrence evidence while balancing safety, service, performance, cost and organisational responsibilities. A risk label becomes useful when it changes the required response.

The captured case defines R1 through R4 actions, from required reduction except in exceptional circumstances to acceptable risk. Use those secure definitions rather than reconstructing numerical boundaries from an unreadable matrix.

ALARP is a proportionality judgement

R2 and R3 sit in the region where further risk reduction is considered against reasonable practicability or cost effectiveness.

The analysis needs available controls, technical feasibility, cost, operational effect and expected improvement. It is not enough to say that current risk is tolerable or that a control is expensive.

The recommendation should show why further effort is required, proportionate or not justified under the relevant response statement.

Service criticality is related but separate

Service criticality highlights customer disruption, operational sensitivity, revenue, public attention and complaint consequences.

A low-cost component can be highly critical when its failure removes an important service or requires scarce restoration capability. Safety risk and service criticality may reinforce each other or point in different directions.

Name both and state how each affects priority, spares, inspection, contingency, renewal or management attention.

RCM starts with required function

Reliability-centred maintenance defines required function and performance, identifies functional failures and credible failure modes, examines local and wider consequences, and selects technically applicable and worthwhile actions.

A task may be scheduled, condition-based, failure-finding, corrective, redesign or another controlled response depending on evidence and consequence.

The method does not require inventing a precise probability where the work history is weak; improving information can be the first decision.

Selective change and assurance matter

The captured railway case reviewed overhaul tasks using safety consequence and probability, service criticality, failure history, characteristics, detection and condition.

The overall cycle moved from 3.25 to four years and most tasks followed a 4-8-12 pattern, while selected safety- or reliability-critical tasks were shortened. Cost-benefit, reliability and safety review, approval, trials and validation supported implementation. The lesson is selective task review, not blanket interval extension.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Risk evidence and response categories R1 to R4

  • 02

    ALARP and proportional risk reduction

  • 03

    Service criticality C1 to C4

  • 04

    Value, priority and non-negotiable boundaries

  • 05

    Function, functional failure and failure mode

  • 06

    Technically applicable and worthwhile maintenance tasks

  • 07

    Selective interval change, trials and validation

Worked example · free

Separate service criticality from safety risk

Q [10 marks]. Not a University marking scheme: AskSia assigns these study marks. AskSia-authored practice. A station subsystem fails frequently and causes short high-profile closures but has no stated safety-critical consequence. Management proposes immediate full replacement. Evaluate the recommendation.
R2 and R3 occupy the ALARP band.R2 and R3 occupy the ALARP band. The ladder preserves the source-defined response for each category without reconstructing the unreadable likelihood-consequence matrix.Required response changes by risk classR1 reduce except exceptional caseR2 reduce if reasonably practicableR3 tolerable, reduce if cost-effectiveR4 acceptableALARP
R2 and R3 occupy the ALARP band. The ladder preserves the source-defined response for each category without reconstructing the unreadable likelihood-consequence matrix.
  • 3Separate the two consequence views.
  • 4Identify evidence and options.
  • 3State assurance and review.
The repeated closures can make service criticality high without proving an R1 safety risk. Use failure history, condition, detectability, restoration and service evidence to compare targeted redesign, maintenance change and replacement. Apply the documented risk response and test proportionality and value. If replacement is selected, define assurance and measures such as recurrence and disruption so the result can be reviewed rather than inferred from completion.
Sia tip — Never let one word such as critical carry both safety and service reasoning. Name the consequence dimension before recommending the control.
Glossary

Key terms

Risk
The effect of uncertainty considered through consequence, occurrence evidence and organisational objectives.
ALARP
A proportionality region in which further reduction is judged against reasonable practicability or cost effectiveness.
Service Criticality
The importance of an asset or failure to customer service and related organisational consequences.
Functional Failure
The inability of an asset to meet a required function or performance standard.
Failure Mode
The specific event or mechanism by which a functional failure occurs.
RCM
A method for selecting maintenance from functions, failures, consequences, evidence and applicable controls.
FAQ

Risk, Criticality and RCM Decisions FAQ

What action belongs to each captured risk class?

R1 must be reduced except in exceptional circumstances. R2 must be reduced if reasonably practicable. R3 is tolerable but should be reduced when doing so is cost-effective. R4 is acceptable. R2 and R3 occupy the proportionality region described in the case.

Is service criticality the same as risk?

No. Service criticality focuses customer and operational sensitivity, while a risk assessment can address safety and other consequence dimensions with occurrence evidence and treatment rules. They may align, but using them separately prevents a high-profile disruption from being mistaken automatically for the highest safety category.

Does the captured RCM case justify extending all intervals?

No. The case changed the overall cycle and extended many tasks, but shortened selected safety- or reliability-critical tasks. It also used review, approval, trials and validation. The transferable method is task-by-task evidence and assurance, not general extension based on one historical success.

Study strategy

Exam move

For one failure, write the consequence evidence and occurrence evidence separately, then apply only the secure R1 to R4 response language. Add service criticality as a second line and state which decision each view changes. Continue with function, functional failure, failure mode, consequence and applicable task. Where evidence is weak, write the information improvement needed instead of inventing probability.

Finish with assurance, trial or review steps and list any critical tasks that do not follow a new overall interval. This protects proportionality and selective reasoning.

Working through Risk, Criticality and RCM Decisions in EE535? Sia is AskSia’s AI Electrical Engineering tutor — ask any EE535 Risk, Criticality and RCM Decisions question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how EE535 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 24 of your subjects at The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your EE535 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works