University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

11359 Chap.5 Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 8 · 11359

Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance

Syntax at the centre

Chomsky defines syntax as the study of how a language builds its sentences.

A grammar, for him, is a device that generates all the grammatical sentences of a language and none of the ungrammatical ones, using a finite set of rules to define an unlimited set of sentences.

Competence and performance

Like Saussure, Chomsky separates an underlying system from its use, but he locates it in the individual: competence is the speaker-hearer's knowledge of the language, performance its use in concrete situations.

The chapter ends with Hymes's objection and his notion of communicative competence.

Why the idealisation matters

Chomsky's object of study is an idealised speaker-listener in a perfectly uniform community. The idealisation removes memory limits, distraction and variation, so that the system itself can be described.

Critics reply that it also removes everything social about language, which is the gap later chapters on functionalism try to fill.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Levels of linguistic analysis

  • 02

    Chomsky's definition of syntax

  • 03

    Grammaticality and meaning

  • 04

    Phrase structure rules

  • 05

    Generativity and creativity

  • 06

    Competence and performance

  • 07

    Communicative competence

Worked example · free

Derive a sentence with the workshop's phrase structure rules

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Using the rules Sentence to NP + VP, NP to D + N and VP to V + NP, with the words a, the, man, ball and hit, derive A man hit the ball and explain why the rules reject Hit man the ball a. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not an official University of Birmingham marking scheme.
One sentence, generated by six rules.One sentence, generated by six rules. Each branch applies a rewrite rule from the workshop grammar, S to NP plus VP, NP to D plus N, VP to V plus NP, until every leaf is a word of The man took the ball .SNPVPD theN manV tookNPD theN ball
One sentence, generated by six rules. Each branch applies a rewrite rule from the workshop grammar, S to NP plus VP, NP to D plus N, VP to V plus NP, until every leaf is a word of The man took the ball.
  • 1Rewrite Sentence as NP + VP, then NP as D + N and VP as V + NP.
  • 1Expand the second NP as D + N, giving D N V D N.
  • 1Insert words: a, man, hit, the, ball.
  • 1The scrambled string has the order V N D N D, which no sequence of rules produces, so it is ungrammatical.
The rules generate the category string D N V D N, and filling it gives A man hit the ball. The scrambled string begins with a verb and ends with a determiner, an order the rules can never produce, so the grammar excludes it. That is what generative means: the rules define exactly which strings belong to the language.
Sia tip — Write the category string before the words; it makes the derivation visibly structural and catches word-order slips at once.
Glossary

Key terms

Syntax
The study of the rules and processes that build the sentences of a language.
Generative grammar
A rule system that generates all the grammatical sentences of a language and none of the ungrammatical ones.
Phrase structure rule
A rewrite rule that expands one category into its parts, such as Sentence into NP plus VP.
Competence
In Chomsky's terms, the speaker-hearer's knowledge of their language.
Performance
How language is really used by speakers in particular situations.
Communicative competence
Hymes's term for everything a speaker must know to communicate well and suitably in social settings.
I-language
Chomsky's later term for the internalised language system, replacing competence.
FAQ

Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance FAQ

Is 'Colorless green ideas sleep furiously' grammatical?

Yes. It is nonsense, but English speakers recognise its structure as well formed, which shows grammaticality can be judged independently of meaning, while the same words reversed are not grammatical.

How do competence and performance differ from langue and parole?

Both pairs separate a system from its use, but langue is a social system shared by a community, whereas competence is the individual speaker's internal, ultimately biological knowledge.

Why did Hymes call the ideal speaker-listener a social monster?

Because a speaker who knew only grammar, with no sense of when, how or to whom to speak, could not communicate appropriately. Hymes proposed communicative competence to include that social knowledge.

What does generative mean in generative grammar?

Not that the grammar produces speech in real time. A generative grammar is a set of rules that defines exactly which strings belong to a language: it generates every grammatical sentence and none of the ungrammatical ones, from finite rules.

What are the levels of linguistic analysis?

The workshop lists phonology for sounds, morphology for the smallest meaningful units, lexis for words, syntax for putting words together, semantics for meaning and pragmatics for meaning in context. Chomsky placed syntax at the centre of linguistics and treated meaning as much less interesting.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Write the three dualities, langue and parole, competence and performance, I-language and E-language, in one table, then sort ten utterance features from your own messages into system or use. Practise one derivation with the workshop rules every few days, varying the words, until you can explain each step aloud.

Before Assignment 1, write a five-sentence answer comparing competence with langue, and check it against the three dualities table.

Working through Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance in 11359? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 Generative Syntax, Competence and Performance question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 11359 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 11359 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works