University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

11359 Chap.4 Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 8 · 11359

Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution

The world Chomsky reacted against

American linguistics in the early twentieth century sat close to anthropology, described individual languages without seeking universals, and, under Bloomfield's positivism, set aside meaning and thought.

Psychology was dominated by behaviourism, and Skinner's Verbal Behavior treated language as stimulus and response.

The review and the revolution

Chomsky's 1959 review of Skinner argued that adult grammar is too complex to be built by imitation and reinforcement, so an internal system must be posited.

The chapter places that argument within the cognitive revolution and sets out Chomsky's three reversals: universals, explanation and creativity.

Reading the history critically

The workshop presents Chomsky as a revolutionary, but it also invites a more careful reading.

The tendencies he rejected each had reasons behind them: anthropological linguists were recording languages that were disappearing, and positivists wanted claims that could be checked.

An evaluative answer acknowledges what each older view was trying to protect before explaining why Chomsky thought it failed to explain language.

Where the chapter leads

The next two chapters follow Chomsky's alternative in detail: first his generative account of syntax and the competence and performance distinction, then Universal Grammar and the critics who still contest it today.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Chomsky's life and early works

  • 02

    Anthropological linguistics and relativity

  • 03

    Description and positivism

  • 04

    Behaviourism and operant conditioning

  • 05

    The 1959 review of Skinner

  • 06

    The cognitive revolution and cognitive science

Worked example · free

State Chomsky's objection to behaviourism in a short answer

Q [5 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. In a short answer, explain the behaviourist account of how children learn language and Chomsky's main objection to it. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not an official University of Birmingham marking scheme.
Chomsky's early landmarks on one scale.Chomsky's early landmarks on one scale. Each dot sits at its year on an evenly spaced line, so the tight cluster from 1955 to 1965 shows how quickly the core generative ideas appeared.1928 born1955 joins MIT1957 Syntactic Structures1959 Skinner review1965 Aspects1975 Reflections on Language
Chomsky's early landmarks on one scale. Each dot sits at its year on an evenly spaced line, so the tight cluster from 1955 to 1965 shows how quickly the core generative ideas appeared.
  • 1Describe operant conditioning: successful actions are reinforced, unsuccessful ones ignored.
  • 1Apply it to language: children imitate adults and are rewarded for correct use, so language is stimulus and response.
  • 1State the objection: adult grammar is too complex to result from imitation and repetition.
  • 1Add the creativity point: speakers produce and judge sentences they have never heard.
  • 1Conclude: an internal grammar must be inferred from behaviour, the core of the cognitive turn.
Behaviourists such as Skinner explained language as learned behaviour shaped by reinforcement: children copy adults and are rewarded for correct forms. Chomsky's 1959 review replied that the grammar adults end up with is far too complex and creative to be produced that way, since speakers handle sentences they have never met. He concluded that linguistics must study an internal system inferred from behaviour.
Sia tip — Name Skinner, the 1959 review and the journal once each; dates and names anchor a short answer about a historical turning point.
Glossary

Key terms

Behaviourism
An approach in psychology that studies only observable behaviour, explaining learning through stimulus and response.
Operant conditioning
Learning in which reinforced actions are repeated and unreinforced ones are dropped.
Positivism
The view that science should deal only with what can be empirically observed.
Cognitive revolution
The shift, from the 1950s, from behaviourism to the scientific study of mental processes.
Cognitive science
An interdisciplinary field that models the mind as an information processor.
Linguistic relativity
The view, emphasised in early American anthropological linguistics, that languages differ deeply and unpredictably.
Stimulus and response
The behaviourist model in which behaviour is a learned response triggered by an outside stimulus.
FAQ

Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution FAQ

What three tendencies did Chomsky react against?

An anthropological emphasis on linguistic relativity, an emphasis on describing individual languages rather than explaining language in general, and behaviourism in linguistics and psychology, best known through Skinner's stimulus and response account of verbal behaviour.

Why was the review of Verbal Behavior so important?

It argued that reinforcement and imitation cannot explain the complexity and creativity of adult grammar. That shifted attention to an internal mental system and made Chomsky a key figure of the cognitive revolution.

What did Chomsky want linguistics to study instead?

Universals rather than relativity, explanation rather than description, and creativity rather than stimulus and response. He pursued all three mainly through the syntax of English, which he saw as the place where universals, biology and creativity meet.

What was the cognitive revolution?

A paradigm shift that began in the 1950s, moving psychology and related fields from behaviourism to the scientific study of mental processes. It produced cognitive science, which treats the mind as an information processor and borrows terms such as input and output from computing.

Where did Chomsky work and when did his key books appear?

He has worked at MIT since 1955. Syntactic Structures appeared in 1957, his review of Skinner's Verbal Behavior in 1959, Aspects of the Theory of Syntax in 1965, and Reflections on Language, which the workshop quotes on Universal Grammar, in 1975.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Make a before-and-after table with three rows, relativity, description and behaviourism, and fill the after column with Chomsky's alternative and one sentence of his reasoning. For each row, add the name of one figure from the workshop, such as Boas, Sapir, Bloomfield or Skinner, so every claim in an answer can carry a name.

Revisit the table after Chapter 6, since the usage-based critics revive a more behavioural account that the 1959 review had rejected.

Working through Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution in 11359? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 Chomsky, Behaviourism and the Cognitive Revolution question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 11359 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 11359 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works