University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

11359 Chap.1 What a Theory of Language Has to Explain

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 1 of 8 · 11359

What a Theory of Language Has to Explain

Why the module starts here

Before meeting any theorist, the module fixes what a theory is. A theory is a set of ideas that explains a phenomenon, the best explanation available given current facts and data. It covers many cases, generates predictions and can in principle be shown to be wrong.

That last property, falsifiability, separates a theory from a slogan.

From explanation to evidence

A hypothesis turns a theory into a checkable prediction, while a model simplifies and describes.

The chapter applies these ideas to a puzzle, why She sneezed the napkin off the table makes sense, and to the question of what counts as language at all.

How theories differ

Theories of language differ in scope and focus.

Generative Grammar concentrates on the underlying structure of a language, Cognitive Linguistics on links between language and general cognitive abilities, and Systemic Functional Linguistics on the purpose an utterance serves. They also differ in foundational assumptions, above all on whether the ability to learn language is innate or comes from experience and exposure.

Keeping both dimensions in view lets you place any later theory quickly.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Theory, hypothesis and model

  • 02

    Falsifiability and prediction

  • 03

    Construction Grammar and caused motion

  • 04

    Scope and foundational assumptions

  • 05

    Working definitions of language

  • 06

    Borderline cases and nonverbal meaning

Worked example · free

Decide whether an invented signal system is a language

Q [4 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Two friends agree that tapping a table once means 'yes' and twice means 'no'. Using the two working definitions of language from the first workshop, decide whether their system is a language. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not an official University of Birmingham marking scheme.
The working loop of a theory.The working loop of a theory. Read the arrows clockwise: a theory generates a hypothesis, data test the hypothesis, and the result either keeps the theory, refines it or forces it to be abandoned.Theoryexplains a phenomenonHypothesisa testable predictionDatatested by observationRevisionkeep, refine or drop
The working loop of a theory. Read the arrows clockwise: a theory generates a hypothesis, data test the hypothesis, and the result either keeps the theory, refines it or forces it to be abandoned.
  • 1Apply the first definition: two people share it to communicate, so as a group's communication system it partly qualifies.
  • 1Apply the second definition: it conveys meaning, but each tap pattern maps to one fixed message.
  • 1Test for structure: the taps cannot be combined to build new messages, unlike words joined by grammar.
  • 1Conclude: a signalling code rather than a language, because structured combination is missing.
The tapping code satisfies the looser definition, since two people share it to communicate, but it fails the stricter one. A language is a structured system for conveying meaning, and here the units never combine into new messages. Calling it a signalling code, not a language, keeps the distinction the module draws between meaning and structure.
Sia tip — Apply both working definitions in turn and say which one your verdict rests on; a single unexplained label reads as a guess.
Glossary

Key terms

Theory
A set of ideas that explains a phenomenon and is the best explanation available given current facts and data.
Hypothesis
A testable statement, usually derived from a theory, that predicts how two things are connected.
Model
A simplified version of something complex that describes a phenomenon rather than explaining it.
Falsifiability
The property of a claim that some possible observation could show it to be wrong.
Construction Grammar
An approach in which abstract sentence patterns carry meanings of their own, independently of the words that fill them.
Speech Act Theory
The view that utterances are actions that perform functions, not only statements that describe.
FAQ

What a Theory of Language Has to Explain FAQ

Why does the module begin by defining a theory?

Every later week tests a theory, so you need a yardstick first. A theory explains, covers many cases, predicts and could be proven wrong; the first seminar asks you to define theory, hypothesis and model, and later answers lean on those distinctions.

How can 'She sneezed the napkin off the table' make sense?

Sneeze normally takes no object, so the verb cannot supply the meaning. Construction Grammar proposes that the abstract pattern subject, verb, object and oblique itself carries the sense of caused motion, which the verb then fills.

Do gestures and intonation count as language?

They clearly carry meaning, as the workshop's analysis of a recorded interview shows, but whether they count as language depends on the definition you adopt. Each theory in the module draws that boundary differently, so state your definition first.

What makes language interesting to study at all?

The first workshop lists many angles: how speakers use signs and join them with grammar, metaphor, how feelings are made vivid, how language reflects social circumstances such as accent, its history, how it is stored in the mind, how it is learned, and how it compares with other species' communication.

What is the difference between a theory and a model?

A model is a simplified version of something complex that describes how it works, while a theory explains why it works that way. A flow chart of a conversation is a model; a claim about why conversations are organised as they are would be a theory.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Write one sentence each for theory, hypothesis and model, then classify five claims from later chapters into the three categories. Revisit the list after each week and note which theory each claim belongs to. Finish each week by asking which side of the innate or learned divide the week's theorist takes, and what evidence they offer for it.

Keep the sneeze sentence as your standard example of a phenomenon that needs explaining, and try to find one more of your own.

Working through What a Theory of Language Has to Explain in 11359? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 What a Theory of Language Has to Explain question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 11359 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 11359 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works