University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

13351 Chap.5 Laing, Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 5 of 11 · 13351

Laing, Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry

Laing on persons

Laing argued that we understand one another as persons through a felt, bodily receptiveness, and that a psychiatry seeing people only as mechanisms is itself pathological.

Drawing on Sartre, he described ontological insecurity, implosion, the divided self and the false self.

Foucault on madness

Foucault's history traces how reason and madness, once intimately related, were radically separated in modernity, and how reforms that removed physical chains replaced them with internalised ones.

The chapter compares the three critics and ends with objections and a seminar case.

Comparing the critics

The three critics agree that mental illness is unlike bodily illness but disagree about almost everything else. The chapter provides a comparison table and a model paragraph, and applies all three lenses to a seminar case of prolonged social withdrawal.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Laing's method and the look of the other

  • 02

    Ontological insecurity and implosion

  • 03

    The divided self and the false self

  • 04

    Foucault's history of madness

  • 05

    Internalised chains and the medical gaze

  • 06

    Objections: romanticising madness and Derrida

Worked example · free

Contrast two critics in one paragraph

Q [5 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Contrast Szasz and Laing on whether mental illness is real, in about one hundred words. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
Laing's account runs from threat to impoverishment.Laing's account runs from threat to impoverishment. Insecurity about one's identity leaves two responses, surrendering to others' gaze or retreating behind a false self, and the lecture follows the second branch to its cost, a shrinking of what the person can do and be. Ontological insecurity Surrender: become object Retreat: false self mask Loss of possibilities
Laing's account runs from threat to impoverishment. Insecurity about one's identity leaves two responses, surrendering to others' gaze or retreating behind a false self, and the lecture follows the second branch to its cost, a shrinking of what the person can do and be.
  • 1Name the shared premise: neither treats psychosis as simply a broken mechanism.
  • 2State Szasz's view: the category is a myth and there are only problems in living.
  • 2State Laing's view: a real change in experience that psychiatry fails to understand.
Both reject a purely mechanical picture of psychosis, but Szasz removes the phenomenon from medicine by calling mental illness a myth, whereas Laing treats it as a real alteration of how a person experiences others, body and world that psychiatry should understand rather than explain away. Ending with the precise point of divergence lets the paragraph do comparative work instead of simply summarising two positions one after the other.
Sia tip — Start a comparison with the premise both thinkers share, then name the exact point where they part.
Glossary

Key terms

Ontological Insecurity
Ontological Insecurity is Laing's term for experiencing relations with others as a threat that could swamp one's identity.
False Self
A False Self is the mask Laing describes a person building to shield an inner self from others.
Medical Gaze
The Medical Gaze is Foucault's term for the clinical way of seeing illness as a lesion located in the body.
Great Confinement
The Great Confinement is the period Foucault describes in which people judged unreasonable were separated and confined.
FAQ

Laing, Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry FAQ

What is ontological insecurity in Laing's account?

It is a sense that relations with other people threaten to overwhelm one's identity. Laing, drawing on Sartre's account of being seen, proposed that people with schizophrenia are hypersensitive to being looked at by others. The threat can intensify into implosion, and the person may surrender to others or retreat behind a false self.

Was Foucault an antipsychiatrist?

In the module interview Lisa Downing doubts that he technically was. Foucault treated mental disturbance less as an individual phenomenon than as a response to a sick society, wrote histories of how madness and normality were produced, and described himself as a historian of the present who offered no programme for reform.

What does the change of chains mean?

It is Foucault's reading of reforms such as Pinel's removal of physical restraints. Instead of freeing patients, the reforms bound them to an internalised idea of normality that they had to display, and in time people learned to police themselves. What looks like humane progress also extends power into the inner life.

Do Laing and Foucault romanticise madness?

The module interviewer suggests both do to some extent, and treats this as an ethical charge: presenting suffering as insight can neglect people who need help. In reply, the interview notes that Foucault had personal experience of mental suffering. If you raise the charge in an essay, point to where in the text the romanticising happens.

What does Foucault mean by a historian of the present?

In the module interview Lisa Downing explains that Foucault looks back at earlier ways of understanding madness not to restore them but to show that present categories are historically produced and could be otherwise. He offers no programme for reform, and his history is discontinuous, tracing shifts in how knowledge is produced rather than steady progress.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Build a comparison table with rows for what madness is, what psychiatry does wrong, method and remedy, and fill one column each for Szasz, Laing and Foucault. Then read the one-page withdrawal case and write a sentence for each thinker's likely reading. End by choosing the objection you find strongest, romanticising madness or Derrida's paradox, and write a paragraph on whether it succeeds.

Keep the withdrawal case in mind as a test: the most useful theory is the one that says most about a real situation.

Working through Laing, Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry in 13351? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 13351 Laing, Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13351 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 13351 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
13351 · Philosophy and Ethics of Mental Health and Wellbeing - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities