University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

13351 Chap.4 Szasz and the Myth of Mental Illness

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters3-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 4 of 11 · 13351

Szasz and the Myth of Mental Illness

The 1960 argument

Szasz's paper in American Psychologist argues that illness is deviation from a norm.

Bodily illness deviates from anatomical and physiological norms; so-called mental illness deviates from psychosocial, ethical and legal norms, so it is better described as problems in living.

The later Szasz

In a recorded discussion at Birmingham he accepted that suffering is real and that help freely sought is acceptable, but held that the conceptual and political analyses are two views of one phenomenon: diagnoses were historically imposed against people's will.

How to use Szasz well

Szasz is easy to caricature and hard to refute.

The chapter separates his conceptual claim from his political one, shows how he answered critics, and locates the premise most open to attack, so that you can engage him in an essay rather than dismiss him.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Physical objects and theoretical concepts

  • 02

    Brain disease as neurology

  • 03

    Illness as deviation from a norm

  • 04

    Problems in living and psychotherapy as ethics

  • 05

    Force, consent and social control

  • 06

    Critics and Pickard's reply

Worked example · free

Reconstruct Szasz's argument and locate its weak premise

Q [5 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Set out the 1960 argument in premises and identify the premise the module's own conclusion page challenges. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
Szasz's fork.Szasz's fork. Every illness claim starts from a deviation, but the left branch measures it against bodily norms and ends in neurology, while the right branch measures it against social and moral norms and ends in problems of living that medicine cannot cure. Deviation from a norm Anatomical, physiological Psychosocial, ethical, legal Bodily or brain disease Problems in living
Szasz's fork. Every illness claim starts from a deviation, but the left branch measures it against bodily norms and ends in neurology, while the right branch measures it against social and moral norms and ends in problems of living that medicine cannot cure.
  • 1Premise: illness is deviation from a norm.
  • 1Premise: bodily illness deviates from anatomical and physiological norms, while mental illness deviates from psychosocial, ethical and legal norms.
  • 1Conclusion: what is called mental illness is a set of problems in living, not illness.
  • 2Identify the weak premise: the narrow, value-free picture of bodily illness.
The argument depends on a contrast between value-free bodily norms and value-laden social norms. The week's conclusion notes that the critics work with too thin a picture of bodily illness; if bodily illness also involves values, the contrast weakens and so does the conclusion. The reconstruction also shows where a defender of psychiatry should aim: at the contrast between value-free and value-laden norms, not at the word myth.
Sia tip — When you criticise Szasz, attack the premise about bodily illness rather than the slogan about myths.
Glossary

Key terms

Problems in Living
Problems in Living is Szasz's term for difficulties measured against social and ethical norms, which he denies are illnesses.
Social Control
Social Control is Szasz's description of medicine's licensed power to restrict people, which he sees at work in psychiatric coercion.
Psychotherapy as Ethics
Psychotherapy as Ethics is Szasz's view of therapy as clarifying and weighing a person's goals and values rather than treating an illness.
FAQ

Szasz and the Myth of Mental Illness FAQ

What does Szasz mean by the myth of mental illness?

He means that illness is deviation from bodily norms, so conditions measured against psychosocial, ethical and legal norms are not illnesses at all. Brain diseases are real but are neurological. What gets called mental illness is better understood as problems in living, so mental illness does not exist while psychological and social problems do.

Did Szasz deny that people suffer?

No. In the Birmingham discussion he said suffering is real but different in kind from backache or toothache, that much can be done to help, and that help must be individual and freely accepted. His objection was to force: he held that you cannot help people with force and that psychiatry depends on it.

Did Szasz change his view in later life?

He denied changing it. When a questioner suggested he had moved from a conceptual claim to a complaint about coercion, he replied that they are two analyses of one phenomenon, one logical and medical and the other political, because psychiatric diagnoses were historically made against people's will.

What is the strongest objection to Szasz?

The module's own conclusion page points to it: Szasz relies on a narrow picture of bodily illness as simple deviation from anatomical and physiological norms. If bodily illness also involves values, the sharp contrast he draws between bodily and mental illness weakens, and with it the claim that only the former is genuine illness.

What reading is paired with Szasz in the module?

Hanna Pickard's chapter Mental Illness is Indeed a Myth, from a collection on psychiatry as cognitive neuroscience. Reading the two together shows how a contemporary philosopher can accept a version of Szasz's slogan while drawing different conclusions, which is a useful model for an essay that agrees with a thesis only in part.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Read the 1960 paper and the module's summary side by side and write the argument in four numbered steps. Then watch the later discussion and list two replies Szasz gives to critics. Finally, read Pickard's chapter, whose title accepts that mental illness is a myth, and write one paragraph on where her conclusion departs from his. That paragraph is a ready-made model for agreeing with a thesis in part.

When you plan, give the conceptual and political analyses separate paragraphs, then show how Szasz himself connects them.

Working through Szasz and the Myth of Mental Illness in 13351? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 13351 Szasz and the Myth of Mental Illness question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13351 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 13351 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 3-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
13351 · Philosophy and Ethics of Mental Health and Wellbeing - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities