13351 Chap.1 Mental Health, Mental Illness and Mental Disorder
Mental Health, Mental Illness and Mental Disorder
What the word mental adds
The opening week asks why psychiatry speaks of mental disorders at all.
The answer offered does not depend on dualism: mental picks out states that are about something, such as beliefs and desires, and capacities judged against standards of rationality and appropriateness.
Norms inside the diagnoses
The chapter reads the diagnostic manuals closely and finds normative vocabulary throughout, separating epistemic norms about belief from moral norms about conduct.
It closes with the language debates, from disorder versus distress to patient versus service user.
Why it matters for your writing
Both assessments reward precise vocabulary. A case study that calls someone a schizophrenic, or an essay that treats a diagnostic description as value-neutral, has taken a position without arguing for it.
The chapter gives you the distinctions to notice those choices and to defend your own.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Why psychiatry needs the word mental
- 02
Intentionality and standards of rationality
- 03
Behavioural descriptions in ICD and DSM
- 04
Epistemic norms and moral norms
- 05
Personality disorders and moral failure
- 06
Choosing words for distress
Worked example · free
Identify the norm a diagnostic description relies on
- 2Unjustified doubts about loyalty concern how beliefs answer to evidence, so they rely on an epistemic norm.
- 2Being unforgiving of insults concerns how one should treat others, so it relies on a moral norm.
- 1Conclude that the description cannot be stated without normative judgement.
Key terms
- Intentionality
- Intentionality is the property of mental states such as beliefs and desires of being about something.
- Epistemic Norm
- An Epistemic Norm is a standard governing belief and knowledge, such as believing in proportion to evidence.
- Parity of Esteem
- Parity of Esteem is the principle that mental health should have the same status as physical health in health services.
Mental Health, Mental Illness and Mental Disorder FAQ
Does calling a disorder mental commit you to dualism?
No. The lecture states that separating the mental from the physical in psychiatry assumes neither that mind and matter are two distinct kinds of substance nor that mental disorders lack physical causes or effects. Mental describes how a condition shows up and is judged: through intentional states and capacities assessed against standards of rationality and appropriateness.
Why do diagnostic manuals use normative language?
Because conditions are identified by how they manifest, and judging a pattern of thought or behaviour as pathological means comparing it with a standard. The manuals speak of inappropriate affect, distorted thinking and failures of interpersonal functioning, which are judgements about how people ought to think or act, not readings from a laboratory test.
Should I write patient or service user in my assessments?
Either can be defended if you explain the choice. The opening lecture notes that patient suggests passivity, while service user presupposes an autonomous choice to use services that is sometimes absent. Many writers follow the language of the person in the case, and the key is to be consistent and aware of what each term implies.
Is dementia an example of a norm being violated?
The lecture uses dementia as an example of epistemic norms being violated, because it involves slower thinking and a falling-off in understanding and judgement. That makes it a useful contrast with personality disorders, whose descriptions in the manuals rely on moral norms about how people should treat one another.
What kinds of philosophical question does the module raise?
The opening lecture lists six kinds: metaphysical questions such as what a mental disorder is, questions in philosophy of mind about how mental and brain states relate, questions in philosophy of science about whether psychiatry is a science, questions of method, ethical questions such as whether a psychopath is morally responsible, and applied questions raised by clinical practice.
Assessment move
Collect three diagnostic descriptions from the lecture and mark every word that expresses a norm. Sort the words into epistemic and moral columns and write one sentence on what that sorting shows. Then draft a short paragraph defending one term you will use for people in your case study, naming the alternative you rejected and why.
Bring both to the first seminar, where the questions ask why schizophrenia and depression count as mental disorders and on what grounds someone could object. Keep these notes: the epistemic and moral columns become a ready-made paragraph for any essay that asks whether psychiatric diagnosis can be value-free.
Working through Mental Health, Mental Illness and Mental Disorder in 13351? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 13351 Mental Health, Mental Illness and Mental Disorder question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13351 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.