University of Birmingham · FACULTY OF ARTS & HUMANITIES

13351 Chap.2 Naturalism, Normativism and Harmful Dysfunction

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters5-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 11 · 13351

Naturalism, Normativism and Harmful Dysfunction

Three families of theory

Following Radden, the lecture sorts accounts of disorder into naturalism, which relies on objectively ascertainable dysfunction, normativism, which relies on harm judged within a framework of values, and hybrid theories that require both.

Testing the definitions

Boorse, Cooper, Wakefield and Reznek each supply a definition, and each meets counterexamples, from rare but healthy traits to diseased plants that cannot be harmed.

The chapter ends by linking these debates to the third week's models of distress, of which the biomedical model is presented as dominant.

Using the debate in an essay

Questions about the concept of disorder make strong essay titles because each position has a clear definition and a well-known counterexample.

The chapter shows how to reconstruct a definition as an argument, choose the hardest case for it, and decide whether to reply or concede.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Radden's three families

  • 02

    Boorse's evolutionary and statistical senses

  • 03

    Cooper's three conditions for disease

  • 04

    Wakefield's harmful dysfunction biconditional

  • 05

    Reznek's hybrid and its questions

  • 06

    Treatability and the five models of distress

Worked example · free

Test harmful dysfunction against a counterexample

Q [6 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. Using Wakefield's two conditions, decide whether a condition that is harmful by cultural standards but has no identified failing mechanism counts as a disorder. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation, not a University marking scheme.
Both circles must overlap for a disorder.Both circles must overlap for a disorder. The left circle holds conditions harmful by cultural standards, the right circle holds failures of evolved function, and the hybrid analysis counts only the shared region as disorder, so either clause alone is never enough. Harm Dysfunction harm alone: not disorder dysfunction alone: not disorder both: disorder
Both circles must overlap for a disorder. The left circle holds conditions harmful by cultural standards, the right circle holds failures of evolved function, and the hybrid analysis counts only the shared region as disorder, so either clause alone is never enough.
  • 2State the analysis: disorder if and only if harm by cultural standards and failure of a mechanism's evolved function.
  • 1Check the harm condition: it is met by the cultural standard described.
  • 2Check the dysfunction condition: without an identified failing mechanism it is not shown to be met.
  • 1Conclude: on the hybrid view the case is not established as a disorder.
Because the biconditional requires both conditions, harm alone is insufficient. The case is not shown to be a disorder until a failure of evolved function is established, which is exactly where critics say the view depends on contestable claims about what mental mechanisms are for. This makes the example a good test case for an essay, because it forces the writer to say how the dysfunction clause could be established for a mental mechanism.
Sia tip — Write both clauses of the biconditional before you test any case; most errors come from checking only one.
Glossary

Key terms

Naturalism
Naturalism is the view that disorder can be defined by facts ascertainable objectively, such as dysfunction, without appeal to values.
Normativism
Normativism is the view that disorder is defined by values, so that a disease is a disvalued or harmful state.
Harmful Dysfunction
Harmful Dysfunction is Wakefield's analysis requiring both harm by cultural standards and failure of an evolved mechanism's function.
Hybrid Theory
A Hybrid Theory defines disorder by combining a factual requirement with an evaluative one.
FAQ

Naturalism, Normativism and Harmful Dysfunction FAQ

What is the difference between naturalism and normativism about disorder?

Naturalism says disorder is a matter of fact, such as a mechanism failing to perform its function, which science can in principle establish. Normativism says disorder is a matter of value: a condition counts as a disease because it is bad to have. Hybrid views, like Wakefield's, require a factual dysfunction and a harm together.

Why is statistical abnormality not enough to define disorder?

Because rarity and illness come apart in both directions. A rare trait such as unusual height is not a disorder, while a very common condition such as gum disease is still a disease. That is why naturalists appeal instead to the failure of a mechanism's evolutionary function, which raises its own questions.

Which models of distress does the module compare?

The third week compares five models: biomedical, harmful dysfunction, biopsychosocial, trauma-informed and instrumentalist. The biomedical model is presented as dominant, and the week examines reasons for and against it and what it implies for classification, diagnosis and treatment.

Is medical treatability a good test of disorder?

The lecture raises the question by asking whether asking if I am ill is the same as asking whether I should go to the doctor. Cooper includes potential treatability among her conditions, but if treatability defined disorder, the boundary of illness would shift whenever a new treatment appeared, which many find unsatisfying.

What problem does Reznek's hybrid view face?

The lecture raises three questions for it: what makes a mental condition abnormal, whether intervention is required to prevent death or merely to improve how someone functions, and how to treat differences that are not experienced as harms, with mania as the example. Each question reintroduces a value judgement that the hybrid view was meant to discipline.

Study strategy

Assessment move

Make a three-column table for naturalism, normativism and hybrid views, and under each write the definition, one case it handles well and one counterexample. Practise reconstructing Wakefield's view as two numbered conditions joined by if and only if, then test it on a case you invent.

Finally, write a paragraph answering the seminar question about whether relying on biological function is an advantage or a disadvantage, taking a side and stating the cost. Then revisit the table after reading Hyman, and note which definition copes best with traits that vary continuously across the population.

Working through Naturalism, Normativism and Harmful Dysfunction in 13351? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 13351 Naturalism, Normativism and Harmful Dysfunction question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 13351 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 17 of your subjects at University of Birmingham, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your 13351 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 5-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works
13351 · Philosophy and Ethics of Mental Health and Wellbeing - independent study guide on the AskSia Library. More University of Birmingham subjects · Microeconomics across all universities