11359 Chap.3 Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs
Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs
From the sign to the system
If signs are arbitrary, what stops a speaker from deciding what words mean, as Humpty Dumpty claims to?
Saussure's answer is structure: each sign's value depends on its position within a language, a social institution no individual controls.
The distinctions that define structuralism
The chapter works through synchronic and diachronic study, langue and parole, value as negative and differential contrast, and the syntagmatic and paradigmatic axes of a sentence.
It closes with Saussure's legacy and three standard criticisms: incomplete arbitrariness, neglect of parole, and the absence of social power from the model.
Using the distinctions in answers
Each distinction is a tool for a particular question.
Synchronic and diachronic tell you which time frame you are describing; langue and parole tell you whether you mean the shared system or one use of it; syntagmatic and paradigmatic tell you whether a relation is one of combination or of substitution. A strong short answer names the tool, applies it to a fresh example and states what it shows about the system.
What this chapter covers
- 01
The Humpty Dumpty problem
- 02
Synchronic and diachronic study
- 03
Langue and parole
- 04
Chess, trains and identity
- 05
Value as contrast
- 06
Syntagmatic and paradigmatic relations
- 07
Legacy and criticisms
Worked example · free
Use langue and parole to describe a word changing its use
- 1Each period's meaning belongs to langue as it stood then, a synchronic state.
- 1Individual uses in speech and writing are parole.
- 1Repeated new uses in parole gradually reshape the shared system.
- 1Comparing the two states is diachronic study.
Key terms
- Langue
- The collective, social system of a language at a given time.
- Parole
- Individual, actual uses of the language system in speech or writing.
- Synchronic linguistics
- The study of a language as a system at one point in time.
- Diachronic linguistics
- The study of how a language changes across time.
- Linguistic value
- The meaning a sign has by contrast with the other signs in its system.
- Syntagmatic relation
- The relation between signs that combine in sequence.
- Paradigmatic relation
- The relation between signs that could substitute for one another in one position.
- Social institution
- Saussure's description of a language as a shared social fact that individuals cannot change at will.
Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs FAQ
What does the chess analogy show?
A knight matters only through its value in the game; a lost piece can be replaced by any object given the same value. Langue is like the rules of chess, and parole like one particular game.
Why did Saussure prioritise synchronic study?
Value depends on contrasts within the system as it stands, and those contrasts may differ at other times. Mixing periods would blur the relationships he wanted to describe, although he spent much of his own career on historical work.
What are the main criticisms of structuralism?
That signs are not always fully arbitrary, that the focus on langue neglects how individuals shape language through use, and that it ignores the power and social context that shape meaning.
What is the difference between polysemy and homonymy?
Polysemy is one word with related meanings, such as the different senses of a word that share a core idea. Homonymy is two unrelated meanings that happen to share a form. Both describe how a particular language system pairs forms with meanings.
What do the trains in Saussure's example show?
The same scheduled train counts as the same train each day even when its locomotive, carriages and staff change, because it is identified by its time, route and contrast with other trains. Signs likewise take their identity from their place in a system, not from their physical substance.
Assessment move
Build a two-column page, langue and parole, and add one example from your own speech each day. For each example, also note one paradigmatic substitute and one syntagmatic partner. Once a week, take a short paragraph from anything you are reading and mark two syntagmatic chains and two paradigmatic substitutions in it.
Close each session by restating the chess analogy from memory, because it compresses langue, parole and value into one image.
Working through Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs in 11359? Sia is AskSia’s AI Arts and Humanities tutor — ask any 11359 Langue, Parole and the Value of Signs question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how 11359 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.