CIVL2102 Chap.9 Failure Criteria and Water Effects
Failure Criteria and Water Effects
A criterion compares a stress state with a boundary
The Mohr-Coulomb criterion represents shear resistance as cohesion plus effective normal stress multiplied by the tangent of friction angle. In Mohr space, critical circles touch a linear envelope.
Cohesion is the intercept, friction angle controls the slope and a tensile cutoff prevents the compression-based line from implying unrealistic tensile strength.
Demand and resistance are different lines
The applied shear stress or transformed stress state is demand. The criterion supplies available resistance from parameters and effective normal stress. Mixing them inside one equation hides the comparison.
A factor of safety or explicit inequality should follow after both are calculated. Confinement matters, so major principal stress alone does not describe failure under a multiaxial state.
Water changes effective stress
Pore pressure is subtracted from total normal stress. Equal pressure on the principal stresses shifts the effective Mohr circle toward lower normal stress without changing its radius.
Frictional resistance falls even if the external load is unchanged. Nonlinear rock response motivates empirical criteria such as Hoek-Brown, while equivalent linear parameters remain tied to a chosen stress range and material scale.
What this chapter covers
- 01
Mohr-Coulomb envelope
- 02
Cohesion and friction angle
- 03
Tensile cutoff
- 04
Demand against resistance
- 05
Pore pressure and effective stress
- 06
Hoek-Brown and fitting range
Worked example · free
Quantify a pore-pressure effect
- 3Calculate dry resistance.
- 3Convert total to effective normal stress.
- 3Calculate wet resistance and interpret the change.
Key terms
- Cohesion
- The zero-normal-stress intercept of a linear Mohr-Coulomb envelope.
- Friction Angle
- The parameter controlling the envelope slope with effective normal stress.
- Tensile Cutoff
- A limit preventing a compression criterion from overstating tensile strength.
- Effective Stress
- Total stress minus pore pressure for the solid skeleton response.
- Tangency
- Contact between a critical Mohr circle and the failure envelope.
- Hoek-Brown
- An empirical nonlinear failure criterion used for rock and rock masses.
Failure Criteria and Water Effects FAQ
Why does water reduce shear resistance?
Pore pressure carries part of the total normal stress, leaving less effective compression across the potential failure plane. The frictional part of resistance therefore falls. The external load can remain unchanged while the effective state moves toward failure.
Why is a tensile cutoff needed?
A straight envelope fitted mainly to compressive states can imply unrealistic tensile capacity when extended left. The cutoff represents the much lower tensile strength and prevents the model from using its compression fit outside a defensible domain.
Are cohesion and friction angle fixed rock constants?
They describe a fitted material, scale and stress range. Values from intact specimens may not represent a discontinuity or jointed mass, and equivalent linear values derived from a nonlinear criterion depend on the confinement interval selected.
What is the fastest effective-stress audit?
Write total normal stress, pore pressure and effective normal stress on separate lines before calculating frictional resistance. Then predict how the Mohr circle or sliding resistance should change. If higher pore pressure increases friction, leaves effective stress unchanged or alters circle radius under equal pressure, revisit the signs and model.
Exam move
Draw the envelope and one circle, then practise three changes separately: greater confinement, greater shear demand and greater pore pressure. Say how the diagram moves before calculating. Label whether parameters describe intact rock, a discontinuity or a mass. Use one line each for demand, resistance and verdict. Begin every problem by identifying the material scale and stress convention.
Cohesion and friction angle for an intact specimen, a filled joint, and an equivalent rock mass are not interchangeable even when the equation has the same form. Write effective normal stress before resistance so that pore pressure cannot disappear inside substitution. On a shear-plane calculation, keep applied demand and available resistance on separate lines and form a ratio or inequality only at the end.
On a Mohr diagram, draw total and effective states in different colours. Equal pore pressure shifts the circle left without changing its radius; changing differential stress alters the radius. Practise predicting those movements before using numbers. Add a tensile cutoff where the linear compression envelope would imply unrealistic tension.
For nonlinear criteria, state the parameter set and stress range rather than converting automatically to one global cohesion and friction angle. Use sensitivity drills by changing water pressure, confinement, or one strength parameter at a time and explaining which part of the diagram changes.
Then connect the mathematical result to a mechanism: a potential sliding plane, confined intact rock around an excavation, or a fractured mass. Review errors by asking whether the chosen criterion describes the observed failure mode and whether the parameters come from compatible tests.
Finish with one observation or measurement that could revise the verdict, such as joint filling, drainage response, confinement, or scale-dependent strength.