The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF LAW

LLAW6132 Chap.2 Berne, Paris and TRIPS: The Treaty Architecture

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
7 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 2 of 10 · LLAW6132

Berne, Paris and TRIPS: The Treaty Architecture

Two families of instruments

The lecture divides the major international instruments into copyright and industrial property. Copyright runs from the Berne Convention through the Rome Convention on performers and broadcasters to the WIPO Internet Treaties and the Beijing and Marrakesh Treaties.

Industrial property runs from the Paris Convention through the Madrid, Hague and Lisbon systems and the classification agreements to the Patent Cooperation Treaty and the plant variety convention.

TRIPS appears in both lists, because its Part II covers every category.

Berne and Paris compared

Berne grew out of authors' campaigns against piracy of European works, was adopted in 1886 and aims to protect authors as effectively and uniformly as possible.

Its basic principles are national treatment, automatic protection and independence of protection, with minimum rights and a minimum term of the author's life plus fifty years. Paris was triggered by the 1873 Vienna exhibition, was adopted in 1883, and covers industrial property in the broadest sense, from patents and marks to indications of source and unfair competition, through common rules rather than a full code.

The lecture gives their membership as 181 and 179.

TRIPS as a trade obligation

TRIPS came out of the Uruguay Round once piracy and counterfeiting were framed as distortions of trade.

It sets a minimum level of protection, permits more, links obligations to WTO dispute settlement, and staged its application: one year for developed countries, five for developing and transition economies with five more for product patents, and ten for least-developed countries, whose period was extended in 2021 to 1 July 2034.

Berne and Paris plus

Through Articles 2.1 and 9.1, TRIPS incorporates almost all the substantive provisions of both conventions.

The one carve-out is moral rights under Berne Article 6bis. The result is that a WTO member outside Berne must still comply with Berne's substance and principles, moral rights aside.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    The copyright instruments from Berne to Marrakesh

  • 02

    The industrial property instruments from Paris to UPOV

  • 03

    Berne's aim, principles and minimum term

  • 04

    Paris scope and its common rules for patents and marks

  • 05

    TRIPS origins in the Uruguay Round

  • 06

    Minimum standards and staged transitional periods

  • 07

    Incorporation of Berne and Paris, and the moral rights carve-out

Worked example · free

Can a WTO member outside Berne deny automatic copyright?

Q [8 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. A WTO member that never joined the Berne Convention introduces a rule that foreign sound recordings and books are protected only after registration. A publisher from another member objects. Advise, identifying the incorporating article and any limit to the argument. The marks shown are an AskSia study allocation and are not the University's marking scheme.
Berne and Paris plus.Berne and Paris plus. TRIPS incorporates almost all the substantive provisions of both conventions by reference, leaves out Berne's moral rights article, and adds its own minimum standards and enforcement.Berne and Paris plus: what TRIPS takes in and what it leaves outTRIPS obligations for every WTO memberParis substancevia Article 2.1Berne substancevia Article 9.1plus minimum standards and dispute settlementMoral rightsBerne 6bis
Berne and Paris plus. TRIPS incorporates almost all the substantive provisions of both conventions by reference, leaves out Berne's moral rights article, and adds its own minimum standards and enforcement.
  • 3Identify how Berne obligations reach a non-party.
  • 3Apply the Berne principles to the registration rule for books.
  • 2Explain why the sound recordings need a separate analysis.
TRIPS Article 9.1 requires every member to comply with Berne's substantive provisions, moral rights excepted, so the member is bound although it never joined Berne. For books, Berne's automatic protection forbids making copyright depend on a formality, and a registration step imposed on foreign works fails that principle and also national treatment. Sound recordings are different: producers of phonograms hold neighbouring rights, and TRIPS national treatment for them applies only to the rights TRIPS itself provides, so the argument must be built from those specific rights rather than from Berne.
Sia tip — Before relying on Berne through TRIPS, check the subject matter. Works of authors travel through Article 9.1; performers, phonogram producers and broadcasters do not.
Glossary

Key terms

Automatic Protection
The Berne principle that copyright arises without registration or any other formality.
Independence of Protection
The principle that a right in one country stands or falls under that country's law, unaffected by its fate elsewhere.
Minimum Standards
The TRIPS approach of setting a floor that members must implement while permitting, but not requiring, more extensive protection.
Transitional Period
The staged delay before TRIPS obligations bound a member, now extended for least-developed members to 1 July 2034.
Moral Rights
The author's personal rights under Berne Article 6bis, the one substantive Berne provision TRIPS does not incorporate.
Industrial Property
The Paris category covering patents, utility models, designs, marks, trade names, indications of source and unfair competition.
FAQ

Berne, Paris and TRIPS: The Treaty Architecture FAQ

Why is TRIPS called a Berne and Paris plus agreement?

Because it incorporates almost all the substantive provisions of both conventions by reference, through Articles 2.1 and 9.1, and then adds its own minimum standards and access to WTO dispute settlement. The plus is the enforcement machinery as much as the extra rules, and the one substantive gap is Berne's moral rights article.

Does Paris set a term of protection for patents or marks?

The lecture presents Paris as a set of common rules rather than a full code. For patents these include independence of protection, the inventor's right to be named and conditions on compulsory licences, and for marks independence, protection of well-known marks and refusal of state emblems. Look to TRIPS for the minimum standards members must now meet.

When does a least-developed member have to comply with TRIPS?

The original ten-year period under Article 66.1 was formally extended on 29 June 2021 to 1 July 2034. Any problem set in a least-developed member before that date should check whether the relevant standard binds yet before finding a breach.

Study strategy

Exam move

Build a one-page table of the three instruments with their adoption dates, membership, principles and the TRIPS articles that link them. Test yourself by covering one column at a time; the short questions in this course reward exactly these facts.

Working through Berne, Paris and TRIPS: The Treaty Architecture in LLAW6132? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LLAW6132 Berne, Paris and TRIPS: The Treaty Architecture question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how LLAW6132 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 26 of your The University of Hong Kong subjects - and 1,000+ Bibles across every Australian university.
Sia - your LLAW6132 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works