The University of Hong Kong · FACULTY OF MANAGEMENT

PMGM7004 Chap.8 Bertrand and Cournot Competition

- one subject, every graph, every model, every mark
6 Chapters4-page Bible
Our own words - no uploaded lecturer files
Updated for this semester
Chapter 8 of 9 · PMGM7004

Bertrand and Cournot Competition

The committed variable selects the model

Bertrand competition treats price as the strategic choice. With homogeneous products, equal constant marginal costs and no capacity constraints, any common price above cost invites a profitable undercut, so equilibrium price falls to marginal cost. Cournot treats quantity or capacity as the strategic choice.

Each firm maximises profit against residual demand, derives a downward-sloping best response and solves the simultaneous intersection.

Additional Cournot firms raise total output and move price toward the competitive benchmark.

Test the undercut with its assumptions visible

The basic Bertrand result relies on buyers treating the products as interchangeable, prices being observed and either firm being able to serve demand won by a small cut.

Differentiation, search frictions or a capacity limit changes the deviation and can sustain prices above marginal cost. A price-matching policy also changes the gain from cutting because the rival may follow immediately.

State which assumption drives the conclusion instead of applying the marginal-cost price as a universal two-firm result.

Derive quantity responses from residual demand

In Cournot, hold the rival quantity fixed, substitute total output into inverse demand and maximise the firm's profit. The resulting response normally slopes downward: more rival output reduces the best own quantity.

Repeat for the other firm and solve the two equations simultaneously. Symmetry is a shortcut only after demand and costs have been shown to match.

Substitution into both responses verifies the intersection.

Use benchmark rankings as an audit

Under common linear assumptions, total output is lowest under monopoly, rises under Cournot, rises again with Stackelberg leadership and reaches the competitive level under equal-cost homogeneous Bertrand. Price moves in the opposite direction.

The ranking gives meaning to an answer and catches many algebra errors, but it does not override changed assumptions. If the order differs, identify whether cost asymmetry, differentiation, capacity or timing explains the result.

In this chapter

What this chapter covers

  • 01

    Price versus quantity choice

  • 02

    Bertrand undercutting

  • 03

    Price matching

  • 04

    Residual demand

  • 05

    Cournot best responses

  • 06

    Market-structure ranking

Worked example · free

Solve a symmetric Cournot market

Q [10 marks]. AskSia-authored practice. The marks shown here are not an official University mark allocation. Inverse demand is P = 30 - q1 - q2 and both firms have marginal cost 6. Derive best responses, quantities, price and operating profits.
With identical products and equal constant marginal cost, any common price above cost invites a profitable undercut.With identical products and equal constant marginal cost, any common price above cost invites a profitable undercut. Repeated undercutting stops at marginal cost, where a further cut would lose money.p2p1 below p2next undercutMCUndercutting stops where another cut would price below cost
With identical products and equal constant marginal cost, any common price above cost invites a profitable undercut. Repeated undercutting stops at marginal cost, where a further cut would lose money.
  • 4Derive both quantity best responses.
  • 3Solve their intersection.
  • 3Recover price and profit.
Each best response is qi = 12 - 0.5qj. Solving together gives q1 = q2 = 8, total output 16 and price 14. Each operating profit is (14 - 6) times 8 = 64.
Sia tip — Hold the rival quantity fixed while deriving one Cournot response, then solve the two responses simultaneously.
Glossary

Key terms

Bertrand Competition
A simultaneous game in which firms choose prices.
Undercutting
Setting a slightly lower price to capture demand from a higher-priced rival.
Cournot Competition
A simultaneous game in which firms choose quantities or capacities.
Residual Demand
The demand left for one firm after treating rival output as given.
Strategic Substitutes
Choices for which an increase by one player reduces another player's best response.
FAQ

Bertrand and Cournot Competition FAQ

Why can two Bertrand firms produce a competitive price?

With identical products and equal constant marginal cost, either firm can capture demand by pricing slightly below any common price above cost. That logic continues until price reaches marginal cost, where another cut would lose money. Differentiation, capacity limits, search costs or repeated interaction can weaken the result.

Why do Cournot best responses slope downward?

A rival's larger quantity reduces the residual demand and price available to the firm. The firm's profit-maximising quantity therefore falls as rival quantity rises. Quantities are strategic substitutes. This direction provides a useful check: a derived response that increases one firm's output when its rival expands usually contains a sign error.

How do I decide whether an industry is Bertrand or Cournot?

Identify what firms commit before demand is realised. Posted prices and rapid price adjustment support Bertrand. Capacity reservations, production schedules or shipping commitments support Cournot. The same industry can require different models at different horizons, and sequential quantity commitment can turn Cournot into Stackelberg.

Study strategy

Exam move

For each industry example, write the committed variable and adjustment horizon before selecting the model. Test a proposed Bertrand price with a one-step undercut. For Cournot, build one firm's residual demand, derive its best response and solve the pair. Finish by ranking total output and price against monopoly and competition so an implausible result is caught immediately.

Change one assumption such as product differentiation or capacity and state why the original deviation test no longer produces the same benchmark.

Working through Bertrand and Cournot Competition in PMGM7004? Sia is AskSia’s AI Management tutor — ask any PMGM7004 Bertrand and Cournot Competition question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how PMGM7004 is taught and assessed. Read this chapter free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.

A+Everything unlocked
Unlocks this Bible + all 52 of your subjects at The University of Hong Kong, plus 1,000+ more Bibles across the AskSia library.
Sia - your PMGM7004 tutor, unlimited, worked the way the exam marks it
The full 4-page Bible + practice bank with worked solutions
Chrome extension - sync your LMS so Sia knows your deadlines
Bilingual EN / Chinese on every Bible and every Sia answer
$0.99 Trial
30-day money-back · cancel in one tap · how it works