JOUR90027 Global Crisis Reporting
JOUR90027 Overview
- University of Melbourne
- Semester 2, 2026
- Graduate coursework
- Presentation, report and essay
- Weekly lecture and seminar
Global Crisis Reporting is a graduate subject taught by the University of Melbourne's Centre for Advancing Journalism.
- Assessed by A group presentation, a two-country media report and a research essay that carries half the mark.
- Hardest step Turning description of coverage into an argument that links named theory to specific stories.
- Pass conditions Attend at least 80% of seminars and submit every task, or you cannot pass the subject.
- How to prepare Read a quality newspaper daily, do the set readings before seminars, and choose your crisis early.
How JOUR90027 is assessed
| Component | Weight | Format |
|---|---|---|
| In-class assessments (group presentation) | 20% | Groups of two or three give a 10-minute presentation in Weeks 2 to 6 on the coverage of a current crisis, with an annotated bibliography; the handbook lists it as equivalent to 1,000 words |
| A1: Media Report | 30% | 1,500 words comparing newspaper coverage of one global crisis in two countries; due 11:59pm, 13 September 2026 |
| A2: Essay | 50% | 2,500-word argumentative research essay on one of nine set prompts; due 11:59pm, 1 November 2026 |
| Attendance hurdle · hurdle | Attend at least 80% of tutorials, seminars or workshops; the subject guide calls this hurdle absolute | |
| Assessment hurdle · hurdle | Submit every piece of assessment, complete and as a genuine attempt to address the task |
Weights follow the University's 2026 handbook record for the subject, which matches the 2026 subject guide. The handbook lists two hurdles: a minimum of 80% attendance at tutorials, seminars or workshops, and submission of all pieces of assessment as complete, genuine attempts; you cannot pass without meeting both. Late work without an extension loses 5% per day. The presentation page says the annotated bibliography is handed in at the end of the presentation, while the presentation slide deck says within a week through the LMS, and the page dates eligible coverage from 25 July 2025; confirm both with your tutor.
Assessment structure
Segment widths are the three published weights, which total 100%. The attendance and submission hurdles sit outside the weighting.
Current JOUR90027 dates
| Date | Item | Control |
|---|---|---|
| Weeks 2 to 6 | In-class group presentation | Presentation page; your group's slot is set in seminars. |
| 13 September 2026, 11:59pm | A1: Media Report | Assignment 1 page and subject overview. |
| 1 November 2026, 11:59pm | A2: Essay | Assignment 2 page and subject overview. |
Dates are as published in the 2026 subject guide and the subject's assignment pages. Confirm exact deadlines and submission settings in the live LMS.
What JOUR90027 covers
Twelve chapters follow the lecture schedule from news values to politically constructed crises, then turn to the media report and the research essay. Each topic links to its free chapter guide.
News Values and the Idea of a Global Crisis
Week 1. The front-page exercise; Galtung and Ruge, Harcup and O'Neill's lists of news values and their 2016 revision; Hall's critique; Cottle on claims-making, power and the definition of a global crisis.The first week asks two linked questions: what makes the news, and what makes a crisis?
- The front-page exercise: ranking four train crashes for one audience
- Galtung and Ruge's twelve categories and Harcup and O'Neill's ten
- The 2016 revision: exclusivity, conflict, drama, audio-visuals and shareability
- Hall and the propaganda model: are news values ideological?
- Cottle: claims-making, power and who defines a disaster
- What journalism is for, and choosing reputable branded sources
Press Systems and Pandemic Reporting
Week 2. Four Theories of the Press; national coverage of COVID-19 in China, Australia and Kenya; Hallin and Mancini's media systems and Christians and colleagues' normative roles; audience fatigue; Kim on democracy and excess deaths.Week 2 uses the COVID-19 pandemic to show that news values are shaped by country as well as by audience.
- Four Theories of the Press and the four basic beliefs behind a press system
- Pandemic coverage compared: China, Australia and Kenya in 2020
- Nolan and colleagues' four kinds of pandemic story
- Audience interest, fatigue and news avoidance in 2022
- Korir and Nabushawo: sourcing hierarchy and normative roles
- Kim on democracy, accountability and excess deaths
War Reporting, Objectivity and Attachment
Week 3. Martin Bell's journalism of attachment versus bystanders' journalism; the neutral observer myth; the camera as participant; good-taste censorship; peace journalism and the reply literature.Week 3 asks what happens to the Western ideal of neutral, objective reporting in a war, especially a patriotic one, and whether peace journalism has a place.
- Bystanders' journalism and the illusion of objectivity
- The journalism of attachment and how it differs from campaigning
- The Sarajevo sniper and the myth of the neutral observer
- The mirror versus the camera: why television changes events
- Good-taste censorship and the call to flinch less
- Ward's reply, peace journalism and essay prompt 5
Climate Change Coverage: Framing and Balance
Climate week. Entman's framing functions; Han, Sun and Lu's six frames in Chinese newspapers; party versus market papers; official sources; balance as bias and how objectivity should apply.Climate change is presented as the biggest and clearest example of a global crisis, and the hardest test of objectivity and balance.
- Entman's four functions of a news frame
- Six frames in Chinese climate coverage, 2005 to 2015
- Party-sponsored versus market-oriented newspapers
- Official sources and the politicising of climate change
- Balance as bias and false equivalence
- Designing a two-country climate comparison
Terrorism, Moral Panic and Bearing Witness
Terrorism week. Lim on reporting terrorist videos in the social media age; precedents from Abu Ghraib to the Foley video; minimising harm; framing of women who joined ISIS; moral panic and bearing witness.This chapter covers the terrorism week, framed in the subject guide around the national interest and how to spot an invented crisis or a moral panic.
- Three transformations of the media environment and the end of gatekeeping
- Symbiosis or exploitation: terrorism and publicity
- Precedents for publishing violence, from the bin Laden tapes to Fox News
- Minimising harm: dignity, propaganda and gratuitous violence
- Framing the women who joined ISIS and the moral panic test
- Lim's nine guidelines as a coding checklist
Crisis Communication, NGOs and Claims-Makers
Claims-makers. NGOs as boots on the ground (Powers); the values behind NGO information; humanitarian numbers and data churnalism (Sunderland and Jackson); corporate crisis management; INGO accountability.Crises need claims-makers to define them in the media, and this chapter asks who those claims-makers are.
- Claims-makers and sponsors of crisis definitions
- NGOs as boots on the ground and the growth of their output
- Powers's four values: accuracy, pluralism, advocacy and timeliness
- Humanitarian numbers, information subsidies and data churnalism
- Corporate crisis management after Deepwater Horizon
- Upward and downward accountability in INGO communication
Unreported Crises: Propaganda, Indexing and Access
Unreported crises. The coverage gap; the propaganda model's filters; indexing theory and Hallin's spheres; journalist safety and access; digital investigation; citizen media.Some crises never become news. This chapter starts from the coverage gap the lecture documents, including CARE's reports on neglected emergencies in Africa and a count of 5.6 million online articles in which almost half concerned Gaza.
- Measuring neglect: CARE's unreported crises and the coverage gap
- Why it's just not news: news values as social constructions
- The propaganda model's five filters
- Indexing theory and Hallin's three spheres
- Danger, censorship and digital investigation
- Citizen media and the right not to be a story
Photojournalism and the Ethics of Crisis Images
Week 8. Linfield on what images can and cannot do; privacy, dignity and verification; Ellis's mundane witness; publishing images of suffering.Week 8 asks what photographs do in a crisis.
- The case for seeing: images that bring suffering close
- Linfield: seeing and doing are not the same
- Privacy, dignity and the ownership of images of the dead
- Verifying images: reverse search and the InVID toolkit
- Ellis's mundane witness and its three elements
- Essay prompt 8: duties to subjects and to the public
Foreign Correspondents and Freelance Risk
Week 9. The changing foreign correspondent; freelancers, stringers and fixers; Wadud's study of freelance climate journalists in South Asia; pay, safety and press freedom.Week 9 looks at being a foreign correspondent, its pressures and priorities.
- The decline of foreign bureaus and the rise of freelancers
- Freelancers, stringers and fixers
- Wadud's four challenges: income, insecurity, status and irregular work
- Pay compared with local entry-level salaries
- Press freedom, safety and the limits of negotiation
- Essay prompt 4: explaining the challenges behind coverage
Populism and Politically Constructed Crises
Week 10. Moffitt's performance of crisis; failure versus crisis; a method for reporting claimed crises; population and refugee 'crises' and their framing.Week 10 asks how to report crises that are politically constructed.
- Failure versus crisis: Hay's distinction
- Moffitt's six steps for performing a crisis
- A five-step method for reporting a claimed crisis
- Two population crises: The Population Bomb and falling birth rates
- Refugees framed as invaders, terrorists and criminals
- Essay prompt 9: credibility and politically charged narratives
The Media Report: Comparing Two Countries
Assignment 1 and the group presentation. Structure, sampling rules, a model research question and approach, and the presentation brief and rubric.Assignment 1, worth 30%, asks for a 1,500-word evidence-based report comparing two countries' newspaper coverage of one recent global crisis, structured like a journal article rather than an essay.
- The report as a journal article: sections and word guide
- Sampling rules: one crisis, two countries, eight to twenty stories
- Eligible sources: branded daily mainstream outlets only
- Writing the research question and justifying the approach
- The five marking criteria and the rubric bands
- The group presentation and annotated bibliography
The Research Essay: Arguing a Position
Assignment 2. What counts as evidence, minimum sources, report versus essay, TEEL paragraphs, a model introduction, style habits and submission rules.Assignment 2, worth 50% and due on 1 November 2026, is a 2,500-word argumentative essay on one of nine prompts.
- What counts as evidence in an argumentative essay
- Minimum sources and the role of media examples
- Report versus essay: purpose, structure and evidence
- Introductions, TEEL paragraphs and conclusions
- Style habits the essay tips warn against
- Referencing, formatting and the submission checklist
It examines how global crises, from pandemics and wars to terrorism, climate change and humanitarian disasters, are reported, and what that reporting means for publics, politics and the people caught up in them.
The subject asks how coverage has changed with digital technologies, how crises are constructed, mediated and communicated, whether journalists should practise a journalism of attachment, how humanitarian organisations communicate, and what moral responsibility news-makers carry when they show human suffering.
Teaching runs through a weekly one-hour lecture and a 90-minute seminar.
The weeks move from news values and Simon Cottle's idea of a global crisis, through press systems and pandemic reporting, war and objectivity, climate framing, terrorism and moral panic, claims-makers and NGOs, unreported crises, photojournalism and foreign correspondence, to crises that are politically constructed.
Readings range from Four Theories of the Press to recent studies of humanitarian data and freelance climate journalists.
The learning outcomes ask you to evaluate key studies and theoretical frameworks, apply them in your own critique of media performance, and adhere to ethical practice under pressure, with accountability and sensitivity toward affected populations.
Assessment is a group presentation worth 20%, a 1,500-word media report worth 30% that compares two countries' coverage of one crisis, and a 2,500-word argumentative research essay worth 50%.
Two hurdles apply: at least 80% attendance at seminars, and submission of every piece of assessment as a complete, genuine attempt; missing either means you cannot pass. The subject forbids generative AI, translation tools and Grammarly for researching or writing assignments.
Worked example · free
Why one disaster becomes a global crisis and another does not
- 1Name the news values the flood satisfies: magnitude, bad news, drama and arresting audio-visuals of a sudden event.
- 1Explain why the drought scores poorly: it is slow, chronic and hard to picture, so it lacks surprise and immediacy.
- 1Bring in Cottle: a crisis needs claims-makers who define it in the media, and scale alone does not guarantee coverage.
- 1Identify who is, or is not, making the claim for the drought, such as aid agencies without access or official attention.
- 1Conclude with a judgement: the gap reflects how coverage is constructed, not the relative size of the two disasters.
Key terms
- News values
- News values are the criteria journalists use to select and rank stories for an audience, such as magnitude, proximity, the power elite, surprise and shareability, listed by Galtung and Ruge and revised by Harcup and O'Neill.
- Global crisis
- A global crisis, in Cottle's usage, is an event or process that the world's news media publicly define, legitimate and mobilise as a crisis, so its status depends on claims-making and power as well as on its scale.
- Claims-maker
- A claims-maker is a person or organisation, such as a government, NGO or politician, that defines a situation as a crisis and promotes that definition through the media.
- News frame
- A news frame is the angle that organises a story, which in Entman's account defines a problem, interprets its causes, judges it morally or recommends a remedy.
- Journalism of attachment
- Journalism of attachment is Martin Bell's term for reporting that cares as well as knows and will not stand neutral between victim and oppressor, while still aiming to be fair and accurate.
- Bystanders' journalism
- Bystanders' journalism is Bell's label for detached war reporting that describes military circumstances from a distance rather than the people who fight and suffer.
- Four Theories of the Press
- Four Theories of the Press is the framework of Siebert, Peterson and Schramm holding that a press system reflects its society, described as Authoritarian, Libertarian, Social Responsibility and Soviet Communist theories.
- Indexing theory
- Indexing theory is the proposition that the press follows what government considers important, so coverage of an issue rises and falls with the attention of officials.
- Propaganda model
- The propaganda model is Herman and Chomsky's account of news shaped by five filters, ownership, advertising, sourcing, flak and ideology, that favour dominant interests.
- Moral panic
- A moral panic is public alarm, often amplified by media, that is out of proportion to a threat and casts a group as a danger to shared values.
- Mundane witness
- Mundane witness is John Ellis's term for the everyday position of viewers who see fragments of distant events through broadcast media and so cannot say they did not know.
- Data churnalism
- Data churnalism is Sunderland and Jackson's term for the recycling of secondary humanitarian figures, often unattributed, from NGO press releases into news coverage.
- Performance of crisis
- The performance of crisis is Benjamin Moffitt's model of how populist actors spectacularise a failure into a crisis, blame an enemy of the people and offer simple solutions.
JOUR90027 FAQ
Is Global Crisis Reporting hard?
The subject guide describes a 170-hour commitment, including 30 contact hours, with weekly readings to complete before each seminar and a requirement to read a quality newspaper every day. Half the final mark rests on one 2,500-word essay, attendance is a hurdle, and the written tasks reward critical argument grounded in theory rather than description, which is where students usually need the most practice.
How is the subject assessed?
There are three weighted tasks: an in-class group presentation worth 20%, a 1,500-word media report worth 30% due on 13 September 2026, and a 2,500-word research essay worth 50% due on 1 November 2026. All are coursework submitted or presented during semester, marked on the University's H1 to N scale against published criteria.
What are the hurdle requirements and attendance rules?
The handbook lists two hurdles. You must meet the minimum of 80% attendance at tutorials, seminars or workshops, which the subject guide calls absolute, and you must submit every piece of assessment as a complete, genuine attempt. You cannot pass without meeting both, whatever your marks on the weighted tasks.
What does the media report involve?
You choose one recent global crisis and compare coverage in branded, daily, mainstream newspapers from two countries, neither of them your home country. You analyse eight to twenty stories from no more than two weeks, use at least five academic sources, and write it like a short journal article with an appendix listing every story's URL.
How many sources does the research essay need?
The instructions set a minimum of two sources from the required reading list and six scholarly sources from beyond it, and say high-performing essays will likely exceed that. You also need examples of contemporary media coverage, used to illustrate positions or representations rather than as a substitute for peer-reviewed research.
Can I use AI tools, translation software or Grammarly?
No. The subject guide states that using generative AI to research or write assignments is forbidden, and the policy extends to translation tools such as DeepL and Google Translate and to Grammarly. Penalties for submitting work that is not your own range from failing the subject to suspension or expulsion.
Which theories matter most for the essay?
It depends on the prompt, but several frameworks recur across the nine questions: Cottle on how crises are constituted in the news, Four Theories of the Press, framing, Bell's journalism of attachment, the propaganda model and indexing, Ellis on witnessing, and Moffitt's performance of crisis. Choose the two or three that fit your prompt and engage with them closely.
Questions students ask in each JOUR90027 chapter
- Why does the subject start with news values?
- Because every later topic depends on them. The front-page exercise shows that coverage is a set of judgements about audiences, and the media report asks you to compare how two national presses made those judgements about one crisis. Chapter 01 · News Values and the Idea of a Global Crisis
- What is Four Theories of the Press?
- It is a framework by Siebert, Peterson and Schramm arguing that a press system reflects its society's beliefs about people, the state and truth. It describes Authoritarian, Libertarian, Social Responsibility and Soviet Communist theories, two of which develop the other two. Chapter 02 · Press Systems and Pandemic Reporting
- What is the journalism of attachment?
- It is Martin Bell's term for reporting that cares as well as knows and will not stand neutral between good and evil or victim and oppressor, while still promising fairness, impartiality and attention to facts. He separates it from campaigning journalism. Chapter 03 · War Reporting, Objectivity and Attachment
- What frames did Han, Sun and Lu find?
- Six: environmental and human impact (22.43 per cent of frame use), attribution of responsibility, collaboration, conflict, leadership and human interest (3.36 per cent). An economic consequence frame appeared in under half a per cent of articles and was dropped. Chapter 04 · Climate Change Coverage: Framing and Balance
- What does Lim argue about terrorist videos?
- That mainstream outlets should acknowledge and contextualise such videos but generally not show them, because they serve the perpetrators' propaganda and harm victims' dignity. She judged self-censorship most ethical for the Foley video and Fox News's full embed of the al-Kasasbeh video ethically indefensible. Chapter 05 · Terrorism, Moral Panic and Bearing Witness
- Why do NGOs matter for crisis reporting?
- Powers argues that as legacy outlets cut foreign coverage, leading human rights NGOs grew their research staff, country coverage and output, partly offsetting losses with their own boots-on-the-ground reporting, some of it designed to look and read like journalism. Chapter 06 · Crisis Communication, NGOs and Claims-Makers
- Why are some crises not reported?
- The lecture offers several reasons: news values that favour dramatic, familiar stories, structural filters described by the propaganda model, coverage indexed to official attention, media bias toward some regions, and practical limits of access, verification and danger to journalists. Chapter 07 · Unreported Crises: Propaganda, Indexing and Access
- Do shocking photographs change policy?
- Linfield argues they rarely do on their own. Images supported movements already under way, as with Emmett Till, but famine pictures from Somalia were followed by a hasty retreat and the Caesar archive changed almost nothing. People, not photographs, create political change. Chapter 08 · Photojournalism and the Ethics of Crisis Images
- Why do outlets rely on freelancers for crisis coverage?
- Wadud links it to profit-driven business models, the decline of foreign bureaus, the lower cost of freelancers and logistical barriers such as visas, security and language that local reporters avoid. Chapter 09 · Foreign Correspondents and Freelance Risk
- What does it mean to perform a crisis?
- Moffitt argues populists do not just respond to crises but stage them: they identify a failure, elevate it to a crisis with urgency, blame an enemy of the people, use media to spread the performance, offer simple solutions and keep the crisis going. Chapter 10 · Populism and Politically Constructed Crises
- How long can the media report be?
- The target is 1,500 words. The FAQ says roughly 1,250 to 1,750 words avoids a penalty, while the General Assessment Guidelines ask for work within 10% of the limit, so 1,350 to 1,650 words satisfies both. In-text citations count; the reference list, appendix, figures and tables do not. Chapter 11 · The Media Report: Comparing Two Countries
- How many sources does the essay need?
- At least two from the required reading list and at least six scholarly sources from beyond it, which can include the further reading list. The instructions call this a minimum and expect high-performing essays to exceed it, and you also need examples of contemporary media coverage. Chapter 12 · The Research Essay: Arguing a Position
How to prepare for the assessments
Work the subject in three passes that match its tasks. During Weeks 1 to 7, read the set readings before each seminar and write a two-sentence note per reading: its central claim and one case it uses, because the media report must engage with literature from those weeks.
Start reading a quality newspaper daily from Week 1 and keep a list of crises that receive sustained coverage in more than one country, so that choosing a crisis for the presentation and report is quick. Treat the presentation as a pilot for the report: analyse two articles for news values, then reuse the frame you build.
For the report, fix your two outlets, your two-week window and your coding questions before you read deeply, and write the approach section first. For the essay, choose a prompt by Week 9, draft a one-sentence argument, and gather at least two required readings and six further scholarly sources, then use the Week 10 and 11 workshops and Week 12 consultations to test your plan.
Throughout, keep notes and drafts, which the guidelines say may be needed to show the work is your own.
Your AI Media tutor for JOUR90027
Stuck on a hard JOUR90027 question? Sia is AskSia’s AI Media and Communications tutor — ask any JOUR90027 Global Crisis Reporting question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how the course is actually taught and assessed. Read this whole study guide free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.