LAWS70271 Patent Law and Policy
LAWS70271 Overview
- The University of Manchester
- 1st Semester 2026/27
- 9 chapters
- Law
LAWS70271 Patent Law and Policy situates UK patent law within its international and European setting, because a patent covering the UK may be granted by the UK Intellectual Property Office or the European Patent Office and is shaped by treaties such as the Paris Convention, the Patent Co-operation Treaty and the TRIPS Agreement.
- Assessed by A 24-hour online open-book examination in which you attempt three questions from six.
- Hardest step Keeping invention, novelty and inventive step apart while applying recent Supreme Court authority.
- How to prepare Read the paragraphs the seminar sheets name and rehearse each topic as both problem and essay.
- Answer habit Construe the claim first, then test the prior art, then advise the client on what to do.
What you get in the full LAWS70271 Exam Bible
- 9 chapters, 43 pages — every examinable topic, week by week
- 24 original practice questions, most with model answers in the 24-hour online examination format
- 9 worked examples, solved the way LAWS70271 marks
- 14 computed figures, redrawn from the course’s own numbers
- Exam-morning plan for the 24-hour online examination (100%) — what to revise last, where marks are lost
Free on this page: assessment table, chapter map, one worked example, key terms, FAQ. The rest is in the full exam bible.
How LAWS70271 is assessed
| Component | Weight | Format |
|---|---|---|
| 24-hour online examination | 100% | Open book. Attempt three questions from six, mixing problem and essay questions. AI Minimal rules apply and a declaration is required on submission. |
| Formative assessment | 0% | Released in Week 5, submitted in Week 7 and returned in Week 9 with feedback. It does not count toward the final grade. |
The 24-hour online examination is the only summative component, so it carries 100% of the unit mark; the formative assessment is returned with feedback and does not count toward the final grade (course unit information 2026/27).
What other students are asking about LAWS70271
- Where can I find lecture notes or study guides for LAWS70271 at manchester?
- The LAWS70271 study guide in AskSia Library covers Patent Law and Policy in 9 chapters, with the assessment table, a chapter-by-chapter topic map, key terms and a worked example, free to read on this page.
- Is there a final exam in LAWS70271, and how much is it worth?
- Yes. In the offering this AskSia Library guide is built from, 24-hour online examination carries 100% of the LAWS70271 mark; the full split is 24-hour online examination 100%.
- What does LAWS70271 cover on the requirement for an invention?
- In AskSia Library's LAWS70271 guide, the The Requirement for an Invention chapter explains week 2. TRIPS Art 27(1), Art 52 EPC, s 1 PA 77, technical character, the DUNS Licensing principles and the end of the Aerotel test.
- What does LAWS70271 cover on computer programs, ai inventions and inventorship?
- In AskSia Library's LAWS70271 guide, the Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship chapter explains weeks 2 and 3. Further technical effect, computer-implemented inventions, COMVIK, neural networks in Emotional Perception and AI inventorship in Thaler.
- What does LAWS70271 cover on novelty, the state of the art and priority?
- In AskSia Library's LAWS70271 guide, the Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority chapter explains weeks 3 and 4. Section 2 PA 77, Art 54 EPC, common general knowledge, making available, priority dates and earlier unpublished applications.
Current LAWS70271 dates
| Date | Item | Control |
|---|---|---|
| 29 September | First lecture | The course asks you to read every page of the first module beforehand. |
| 9 November, 16:00 | Formative assessment submission | Does not count toward the final grade; one line of the submission page prints an earlier year, so follow the live page. |
| Week of 7 December | Compulsory licensing workshop | Simulated meetings; attendance is compulsory. |
Dates are as published in the 2026/27 teaching schedule and module pages. Confirm exact deadlines and submission settings in the live LMS.
What LAWS70271 covers
Nine chapters follow the module from why patents exist and how they are granted, through invention, novelty, inventive step and the exceptions, to infringement and access to medicines under TRIPS.
Patent Rationales, Institutions and Post-Grant Challenges
Weeks 1 and 2. Justifications for patents, the patent bargain, treaties and the Patents Act 1977, filing routes, claims, rights conferred, opposition and revocation.Patent Rationales, Institutions and Post-Grant Challenges sets the frame for the whole module.
- Natural rights, incentive and disclosure justifications
- The patent bargain in Actavis v ICOS and Liardet v Johnson
- Paris Convention, TRIPS, PCT, EPC 2000 and the Patents Act 1977
- UK courts, EPO boards and the Unified Patent Court after Brexit
- Application contents, disclosure and the role of claims
- Opposition under Art 99 EPC and revocation under s 72 PA 77
The Requirement for an Invention
Week 2. TRIPS Art 27(1), Art 52 EPC, s 1 PA 77, technical character, the DUNS Licensing principles and the end of the Aerotel test.The Requirement for an Invention explains a puzzle at the centre of patent law: neither TRIPS, the EPC nor the Patents Act defines an invention.
- TRIPS Art 27(1) and the undefined invention
- Art 52(1) to (3) EPC 2000 and s 1(1) and (2) PA 77
- Technical character and the technical teaching
- The DUNS Licensing principles (a) to (g)
- Why the Aerotel test was overruled
- The approach at [67] of Emotional Perception
Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship
Weeks 2 and 3. Further technical effect, computer-implemented inventions, COMVIK, neural networks in Emotional Perception and AI inventorship in Thaler.Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship applies the invention test to the field where it is most contested.
- Why programs are excluded and TRIPS Art 10
- Further technical effect under the EPO Guidelines
- Computer-implemented inventions and the any hardware approach
- COMVIK and the inventive step filter
- Artificial neural networks in Emotional Perception
- Section 7 PA 77, Rhone-Poulenc and the Thaler decisions
Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority
Weeks 3 and 4. Section 2 PA 77, Art 54 EPC, common general knowledge, making available, priority dates and earlier unpublished applications.Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority explains what counts against an invention and from which date.
- Section 2(1) and (2) PA 77 and Art 54 EPC
- Common general knowledge in Idenix v Gilead and Regen Lab
- Made available: emails, web pages and analysable products
- First to file, s 5(1) and the twelve-month priority right
- Unwired Planet v Huawei and the time zone of filing
- Earlier applications under s 2(3) and disregarded disclosures under s 2(4)
Anticipation: Disclosure and Enablement
Weeks 3 and 4. Necessary infringement, enabling disclosure, Synthon, Dyson v Samsung, prior use, secret use and publication.Anticipation: Disclosure and Enablement tests whether a particular item of prior art takes away a claim's novelty.
- Anticipation as a term of art and an invention as information
- Disclosure: necessary infringement and clear directions
- Enablement and the assumed willingness to experiment
- Prior use, secret use and uninformative use
- Publication: potentially available and directly accessible
- Why Synthon keeps disclosure and enablement apart
Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art
Weeks 4 and 5. The novelty and obviousness boundary, the problem and solution approach, mosaicking and the Seminar 2 cyclone problem.Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art picks up where novelty ends.
- The Synthon boundary between novelty and inventive step
- The EPO problem and solution approach
- Technical features only after COMVIK
- Mosaicking documents for novelty and for obviousness
- Optional wording and clear directions in prior art
- The Samaria and Drydon cyclone problem
Medical Method and Morality Exceptions
Weeks 7 and 8. Medical and veterinary methods, claim wording, Art 53(a) morality, biotechnology and third parties in oppositions.Medical Method and Morality Exceptions covers subject matter that may be a technical invention and yet be refused protection.
- Medical and veterinary methods in the teaching schedule
- Claim wording such as non-therapeutic and its limits
- Art 53(a) EPC, morality and ordre public
- Schedule A2 and Directive 98/44 on biotechnology
- Opposition as the route for third-party intervention
- Faith groups and ethicists as opponents
Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies
Weeks 8 to 10. The four tasks, s 60 acts, Actavis v Eli Lilly, Art 69 EPC and its Protocol, defences and remedies.Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies moves from validity to enforcement.
- The four tasks of an infringement answer
- Acts that infringe under s 60 PA 77
- Normal interpretation and the inventive concept
- Infringement by equivalents under Actavis v Eli Lilly
- Section 125(3) PA 77, Art 69 EPC and its Protocol
- Defences, remedies and the Chica and Revine problem
TRIPS Flexibilities and Access to Medicines
Weeks 10 and 11. TRIPS minimum standards, flexibilities, the Doha Declaration, compulsory licensing and the simulated meeting workshop.TRIPS Flexibilities and Access to Medicines closes the module with its policy component.
- Medicine supply during a public health emergency
- TRIPS Article 1 minimum standards and more extensive protection
- TRIPS Article 27(1) and patent availability
- Flexibilities, the Doha Declaration and compulsory licensing
- The policy role of WIPO and the World Health Organisation
- The simulated meeting workshop and reflection
The module begins with why patents exist at all, comparing natural-rights, incentive and disclosure justifications, and with how an application is made, what the specification and claims must contain, and how a granted patent can be opposed or revoked.
The substantive core follows the conditions for a valid patent.
You learn why the law never defines an invention and instead excludes discoveries, mathematical methods, business methods and computer programs as such, and how the Supreme Court in Emotional Perception replaced the Aerotel test with the DUNS Licensing principles used at the European Patent Office.
Artificial intelligence runs through this part, both as subject matter, in the treatment of artificial neural networks, and as a putative inventor after Thaler.
Novelty, anticipation and inventive step are then taken in turn, with the boundary between them drawn through Synthon, Dyson v Samsung and the Seminar 2 cyclone problem.
The later weeks examine the medical and veterinary methods exception and the role of morality in patenting biological material, then claim construction and infringement after Actavis v Eli Lilly, with defences and remedies.
The policy component closes the module with TRIPS minimum standards and flexibilities, the Doha Declaration and a compulsory licensing workshop on getting medicines to patients when a public health emergency strikes.
Assessment is a 24-hour online open-book examination in which you attempt three questions from six, mixing problem and essay questions, under the University's AI Minimal rules.
LAWS70271 cheatsheet for the final exam
AskSia publishes a free LAWS70271 cheatsheet for the final exam, an open-book exam sheet that follows the official permitted-materials rule for this assessment and condenses the topics in this guide.
Worked example · free
Sort three earlier disclosures under section 2
- 1Fix the priority date first: absent an earlier filing, s 5(1) makes it the filing date of 14 June, judged from the start of that day. The marks shown here are an original practice allocation, not a published university marking scheme.
- 2The April poster was made available to the public before the priority date, so it forms part of the state of the art under s 2(2), provided the device was shown without any duty of secrecy.
- 2The competitor's application is published after 14 June but has an earlier priority date, so the matter it contained both as filed and as published is deemed part of the state of the art under s 2(3).
- 1The February disclosure falls within the six months before filing and was made in breach of confidence, so s 2(4) requires it to be disregarded.
Key terms
- Patent bargain
- The exchange in which an inventor receives a time-limited monopoly in return for disclosing the invention to the public.
- Technical character
- The quality a claimed subject matter needs to count as an invention, meaning a technical teaching that solves a technical problem.
- Excluded subject matter
- Matter such as discoveries, mathematical methods, business methods and programs that is not an invention to the extent claimed as such.
- Further technical effect
- An effect of a computer program beyond the normal interaction between software and hardware, which gives the program technical character.
- Computer-implemented invention
- A claim involving computers or programmable apparatus in which at least one feature is realised by a program.
- State of the art
- Everything made available to the public anywhere before the priority date, by description, use or any other way.
- Priority date
- The date on which novelty is judged, normally the filing date or an earlier first filing within twelve months.
- Common general knowledge
- Knowledge that most people working in a field treat as a reliable footing for further work.
- Anticipation
- Prior art that discloses and enables subject matter whose performance would necessarily infringe the claim.
- Enabling disclosure
- A disclosure that lets the skilled person perform the invention without inventive effort or prolonged research.
- Inventive step
- The requirement that an invention would not have been obvious to the skilled person at the priority date.
- Infringement by equivalents
- Infringement by a variant outside a normal interpretation of the claim, decided under the second Actavis step.
- Compulsory licence
- A licence to work a patented invention granted without the owner's consent, discussed here for medicines under TRIPS.
LAWS70271 FAQ
How difficult is this module?
The difficulty lies in reading primary authority closely. The seminar sheets send you to particular paragraphs of Supreme Court and Court of Appeal judgments, and the course information warns that preparation takes longer than expected, especially if the common law is new to you or English is a second language. The 2026 Emotional Perception decision also changed the law on excluded subject matter.
How is the module assessed?
The course information names a 24-hour online open-book examination in which you attempt three questions from six, mixing problem and essay questions. It does not print a percentage weight. A formative assessment is released in Week 5 and submitted in Week 7; it does not count toward the final grade but gives written feedback before the examination.
What does the examination look like?
Six questions are set, mixing problem questions that ask you to advise a client and essay questions that ask you to evaluate law or policy. You choose any three and have 24 hours online with open-book conditions. A video on the module site explains the assessment, so watch it and plan which topics you will prepare as problems and which as essays.
Can I use AI tools in the examination?
The assessment is classed as AI Minimal. AI may be used only to improve presentation, such as grammar, spelling, formatting and typographical errors, without changing substantive content. Translating your own draft, inserting or paraphrasing AI-generated text, or asking AI to improve your academic style are all prohibited, and you must declare compliance when you submit.
Are past papers available?
The module site links to past examination papers and warns that course content and paper structure may change from year to year. Those papers are not reproduced in this guide. The practice questions here are original and follow the problem and essay styles of the seminar sheets, so use the official papers for timing and these for method.
Are the seminars and workshop compulsory?
Yes. The course information states that attendance is compulsory at all four seminars and at the two-hour problem-based learning workshop. The seminars cover invention, novelty and inventive step, exceptions, and infringement, while the workshop uses simulated meetings on compulsory licensing and medicine supply during a public health emergency.
What should I revise first?
Start with the requirement for an invention, computer programs and AI, because Emotional Perception reshaped the area and Seminar 1 tests it. Then secure novelty and inventive step together, since their boundary drives most validity problems. Finish with infringement after Actavis v Eli Lilly, the exceptions, and the TRIPS material, which suits essay questions on policy.
Questions students ask in each LAWS70271 chapter
- Why does patent law give inventors a monopoly?
- The leading account in the course is the bargain: Lord Hodge explains that the monopoly rewards innovation and, in exchange, the inventor discloses the invention and dedicates it to the public once protection ends. Natural-rights and incentive theories are also examined, along with criticism that utilitarian claims lack empirical support. Chapter 01 · Patent Rationales, Institutions and Post-Grant Challenges
- Why is invention never defined in the statutes?
- TRIPS leaves the term open so that new fields such as computer science, biotechnology and nanotechnology can be covered, and Correa reads this as giving Members room to define it in good faith. The EPO likewise relies on a negative list of non-inventions plus the technical character requirement. Chapter 02 · The Requirement for an Invention
- Can software be patented in the UK?
- A claim involving a computer now passes the invention test because the hardware gives technical character, so the program is not claimed as such. Patentability then depends on inventive step, where only technical features count. A claim whose only novelty is a business rule or algorithm without technical effect will usually fail there. Chapter 03 · Computer Programs, AI Inventions and Inventorship
- What date is novelty judged at?
- Novelty is judged at the priority date, which s 5(1) makes the filing date unless an earlier application is validly claimed. The assessment is made at the beginning of that day, so a disclosure on the priority date itself does not anticipate the invention. Chapter 04 · Novelty, the State of the Art and Priority
- Why must disclosure and enablement be kept separate?
- Lord Hoffmann in Synthon explained that confusing them distorts the test. For disclosure, the art must describe something that would necessarily infringe, and the skilled person cannot fill gaps by invention. For enablement, once that subject matter is disclosed, the skilled person is assumed willing to experiment by trial and error. Chapter 05 · Anticipation: Disclosure and Enablement
- What is the difference between lack of novelty and obviousness?
- Lack of novelty requires prior art that would necessarily infringe if performed. Obviousness covers art that would not itself infringe but would make it obvious to the skilled person how to adapt it into something that does. Synthon at [25] uses exactly that line, citing General Tire v Firestone. Chapter 06 · Inventive Step and Mosaicking Prior Art
- Why can a valid invention still be refused a patent?
- Some subject matter is excepted for policy reasons even if it is technical, new and inventive. The module covers medical and veterinary methods and the morality and ordre public exclusion in Art 53(a) EPC, together with the special rules for biotechnological inventions in Schedule A2 of the Patents Act. Chapter 07 · Medical Method and Morality Exceptions
- How do I structure an infringement answer?
- Follow the four tasks in the Seminar 4 tips: identify the type of infringing activity under s 60, decide whether it falls within the scope of the claims, consider defences, and choose a remedy. Run the tasks separately for each activity of the defendant, because different acts can lead to different advice. Chapter 08 · Infringement, Claim Scope, Defences and Remedies
- What is the policy question at the end of the module?
- It asks how a country that cannot manufacture medicines itself can obtain patented medicines and vaccines once a public health emergency begins. The module approaches it through TRIPS minimum standards and flexibilities, the Doha Declaration and compulsory licensing, culminating in a workshop. Chapter 09 · TRIPS Flexibilities and Access to Medicines
How to study for the exam
Study LAWS70271 as a sequence of tests that a court applies in a fixed order. For every topic, build a one-page authority sheet: the statutory provision, the European equivalent, the leading case with its paragraph reference, and one sentence on how the rule is applied. Then practise each topic twice, once as a problem in which you advise a client and once as an essay in which you take a position.
For validity, rehearse the order invention, novelty, inventive step, exceptions, and keep disclosure and enablement visibly separate inside novelty. For infringement, follow the four tasks from the Seminar 4 tips: classify the act, decide scope through the two Actavis steps, consider defences, then choose a remedy. Use the formative assessment as a full rehearsal and act on its feedback.
In the final weeks, index your notes by topic for the open-book paper, write at least one timed answer for each likely question type, and check every conclusion against the question actually asked.
Your AI Law tutor for LAWS70271
Stuck on a hard LAWS70271 question? Sia is AskSia’s AI Law tutor — ask any LAWS70271 Patent Law and Policy question and get a clear, step-by-step explanation grounded in how the course is actually taught and assessed. Read this whole study guide free, then take your hardest questions to Sia.